Skip to Content

11 Best Stuffed Banana Pepper Recipes

11 Best Stuffed Banana Pepper Recipes

For quick and delicious meals, check out this impressive collection of stuffed banana pepper recipes that features comforting soups and hearty pasta entrées. 

Have you heard of banana peppers?

No, they aren’t a cross-breed between bananas and peppers.

They are, however, a kind of pepper that looks quite like a banana with their long, banana-like figure and their bright yellow hue.

Banana peppers don’t taste like bananas, though, they are subtly sweet but mostly tangy and have little to no heat at only around 500 Scoville units.

They are also known by the names, banana chili or yellow wax pepper.

These beautiful peppers are great eaten raw, pickled, topped as a garnish, and a favorite among many—stuffed.

We have curated some of the best stuffed banana pepper recipes for you to make with your own cute yellow peppers.

You’ll be surprised that stuffed peppers can actually be made into soup, curried, and mixed with pasta.

Not only that but there are a lot of flavor combinations that go with these beautiful peppers.

Cheese, for instance, is one of the staple ingredients that go well with them!

They are great to serve for guests because they already look amazing even without much effort.

Now raid your fridge and local markets for these stunningly delicious yellow peppers, and let’s get stuffing!

These stuffed banana peppers have sausages and cheese in every bite.

They are perfect for a snack or as part of a big meal.

These Cheesy Stuffed Banana Peppers can be made by batch and frozen so that you can cook them quickly and easily whenever you like.
Ingredients include: Banana peppers, sausage, cream cheese, cheddar cheese, and garlic salt and pepper.

We bet you didn’t expect soup on this list.

This may be a pleasant surprise to encounter, though, because this dish is not only easy, it’s quite tasty too!

Meaty, creamy, tangy, subtly sweet and just a tad bit spicy, and a hundred percent delicious.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, dry orzo, mild ground Italian sausage, chicken stock, and evaporated milk.

This version of stuffed banana peppers has a lovely Asian-inspired taste!

It has pork and prawn meat, red chilies, and fresh coriander.

Thai curry paste, coconut milk, and fish sauce provide the authentic flavors of Thai cuisine.

Enjoy it with your favorite steamed rice for an amazing meal.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, minced pork, prawn meat, Thai green or red curry paste, and coconut milk.

Here’s a stuffed banana pepper with the flavors of your favorite buffalo wings.

It has the perfect balance between the creamy cheese, the freshness of banana peppers, and the spicy taste and tang of the hot pepper sauce.

They are tasty appetizers or movie-watching snacks.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, cooked chicken, cream cheese, parmesan cheese, and hot wing sauce.

If you like spinach and cheese meals, then you’ll love these.

It’s a simple dish that you can make with canned tuna.

These are perfectly light and extremely flavorful with all the different spices, cheeses, and even non-pareil capers.

Non-pareil capers are top-quality capers that are small but bursting with flavor.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, canned albacore tuna, mozzarella, baby spinach, and non-pareil capers.

These banana pepper bites are so good that having just one won’t be enough.

Thankfully there are plenty to go around.

These small bite-sized stuffed banana peppers are perfect for snacks or appetizers.

You can make them for sharing or to eat up all on your own.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, cream cheese, green onions, bacon, eggs, and panko.

This colorful meal is not just a feast for the eyes but also a delicious dish for your taste buds.

It’s stuffed with the classic feta and pecorino romano or kefalotyri.

If you haven’t heard of this unique-sounding cheese, then you’re in for a treat.

This hard cheese is made with goat or sheep cheese and is salty, tangy, and spicy.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, feta cheese, red chili flakes, fresh cilantro, and pecorino romano or kefalotyri.

Goat cheese or chevre is cheese made from goat’s milk.

It is a soft tart cheese with a buttery yet earthy flavor.

Mixed with sausages and stuffed in banana peppers, they are a great combination of savory, tangy, and a bit of sweet, spicy flair.

The balsamic glaze, on the other hand, gives it a flavor kick.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, hot Italian sausage, goat cheese, and balsamic glaze.

This stuffed banana pepper dish may need more ingredients and a bit more preparation, but it’s all worth it.

If you haven’t tried tuna on curry yet, then this just might be the dish to get you started.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, green chilies, curry leaves, coconut milk, and red chili powder or cayenne powder.

This stuffed banana pepper recipe is perfect to make when you’ve got a surplus of summer vegetables.

You’d be surprised to find out that it has no meat or any animal by-products in it at all.

The nutritional yeast adds a flavor that resembles cheese without actual dairy products.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, zucchini, carrots, nutritional yeast, and chives.

This Italian flavor-inspired dish has the knockout flavors of marinara sauce, cheese, and Italian seasoning.

Serve them with some steamy rice or your favorite pasta.

For a lighter option, you can try serving it with some shirataki or zucchini noodles or even some cauliflower rice.

Serve it with your favorite drinks for the ideal meal.

Ingredients include: Banana peppers, Italian sausage, marinara sauce, cream cheese, and parmesan cheese.

The bottom line

Next time you have some of these beautiful yellow peppers lying around, you may want to gather up some of your favorite ingredients to make some of these stuffed dishes.

Banana peppers change colors as they ripen, and different stages of ripeness of banana peppers will look really great when plated together.

These are great for entertaining guests or if you just want something new to add to your home recipe arsenal.

If you’re not a fan of spice, you don’t even have to worry because these peppers are not at all on the hot side of the spice scale.

Meats and cheeses complement the tangy, sweet, and mild spiciness of the banana peppers.

Try out any one of these stuffed banana pepper dishes as is, or give it your spin.

Serve them with your favorite sides or entrees, depending on the flavors that complement your stuffed banana pepper dish.

More About Banana Peppers

11 Best Stuffed Banana Pepper Recipes

11 Best Stuffed Banana Pepper Recipes

For quick and delicious meals, check out this impressive collection of stuffed banana pepper recipes that features comforting soups and hearty pasta entrées.


  • Cheesy Stuffed Banana Peppers
  • Stuffed Banana Pepper Soup
  • Thai-Style Stuffed Banana Peppers
  • Buffalo Chicken Banana Peppers
  • Tuna & Spinach Stuffed Banana Peppers
  • Stuffed Banana Pepper Bites
  • Colorful Feta Stuffed Banana Pepper
  • Sausage And Goat Cheese Stuffed Banana Peppers
  • Tuna Stuffed Banana Pepper Curry
  • Banana Peppers Stuffed With Summer Vegetables
  • Italian Sausage Stuffed Banana Peppers


  1. Skim through our Stuffed Banana Pepper Recipes list.
  2. Select the recipe that looks good.
  3. Prep the ingredients as instructed.
  4. Be sure to share this list of foodie finds!

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe