Skip to Content

Banana pepper recipes: 15 uber-tasty entries

You’ve ventured into vegetable gardening, and now your efforts have paid off–it’s harvest time!

After collecting the greens, you found out that you have extra banana pepper. Consequently, you landed here to figure out the delicious ways to use your banana peppers.

For those unfamiliar with the veggie, banana pepper or banana chili is a yellow chili pepper that features a hint of tangy, mild, and slightly sweet taste. This vegetable adds flavor to your favorite salsa, pizza, salads, and sandwiches. 

So if you’re struggling with what to do with your banana peppers, then this essential guide should answer your dilemma! 

Without further ado, here are my top 15 banana pepper recipes that are will convince you not to throw your leftover banana chili. 

1. Stuffed banana peppers

Packed with exciting flavors coming from sauteed chorizo, goat cheese, basil, and chives, this recipe is sure to make banana peppers your new favorite veggie. 

The combination of the main ingredients in the dish creates a dazzling taste that’s being improved by the presence of Italian seasoned panko and paprika toppings. 

Get the recipe here.

2. Pickled banana peppers

Another good way to make use of your extra banana peppers is to pickle them! It’s too simple to create, yet the final product is so delish. All you need is salt, vinegar, water, garlic, fresh dill, and you’re good to go!

Quick note: Make sure to wash the veggies well and can them in a water bath canner to kill those bacteria that can make you sick. 

Unlock this recipe here.

3. Banana pepper ketchup

If you’re tired of your same old ketchup for your french fries, then having a new dipping sauce should be on your priority list!

Behold, the banana pepper ketchup! Just don’t be surprised how straightforward this recipe is. And you don’t need those fancy ingredients to make one. Just secure some ketchup and diced banana peppers, then mix them in a bowl. You’re welcome!

Find the complete details here.

4. Hot sausage-stuffed banana pepper

Every bite of this hot sausage stuffed banana pepper will leave you coming back for more. The ingredients behind the dish’s heavenly goodness are the Italian sausage ground, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese topping.

If you don’t like it spicy, then I suggest removing all of the banana pepper seeds before stuffing the meat. Also, you can use ground beef, mild sausage, or fatty meat if you opt for something different. 

Here’s the recipe.

5. Banana pepper and bacon hot dip

If you love everything about bacon, then this recipe should be your default dip from now on!

This cheese dip features shredded pepper jack cheese, cream cheese, yellow onion, and garlic. The combination of tangy, delicious banana peppers and crispy bacon toppings go the extra mile for deliciousness. 

Try to serve it with tortilla chips at your next movie night, and you’ll get the thumbs up from your family. 

Get the recipe here.

6. Banana pepper salsa

If you’re still wondering what to make with banana peppers, then this next candidate should do the work!

Aside from your fresh banana peppers, this salsa also calls for jalapeno, tomatoes, garlic, onion, cilantro, lime juice, and vinegar. The recipe can be served as a stand-alone with chips or topping to your favorite Mexican dishes. 

Unlock this recipe here.

7. Fried banana peppers

These fried banana peppers are delicious when served along with a bowl of steaming hot chili, ranch, or blue cheese dressing. Yum! If you haven’t tried this combo, you’re missing out big time!

This recipe is not your typical finger food. It’s crispy, flavorful, and addicting. The preparation is simple: drain the fresh banana peppers, chop the veggies, toss in flour, and fry them until it reaches the golden brown perfection!

Whether you put them on burgers, toss them in salad or tacos, nothing goes wrong with these fried banana peppers!

Get the recipe here.

8. Bacon and banana peppers grilled cheese

The addition of banana peppers in this cheesy sandwich gives a kick to its overall flavor profile. Meanwhile, the sprinkling of real bacon bits over the mozzarella cheese creates a nice crunchy texture that you shouldn’t miss. 

You can use either regular butter or margarine as a spread on your bread. But if you happen to have garlic butter, use it as it adds great flavor to your sandwich. 

Here’s the recipe.

9. Stuffed banana pepper soup

Who says you can’t turn your banana pepper into a fabulous soup? 

This banana pepper recipe is laden with that slight spiciness and creaminess you always wanted in a soup dish. It’s ideal for serving lunch dinner on any occasion!

You might be overwhelmed by its ingredients and steps, but the recipe is totally worth making. Plus, creating it is a great way to use the abundance of banana peppers your garden produces!

Get the recipe here.

10. Cheese stuffed banana peppers

Bacon and banana pepper are born together. If you’re not convinced enough, then try a bite of these cheese-stuffed banana peppers. 

The banana peppers are stuffed with cheddar cheese, cream cheese, tomato, onion, bell pepper, jalapeno, then wrap with a bacon slice before being broiled for a few minutes. 

A quick tip: Secure the peppers with a toothpick to hold things together. 

More details about this recipe here.

11. Salami and banana pepper stromboli

Salami, pizza crust, banana peppers, shredded Italian cheese, butter, garlic, and herb salt are the ingredients needed to make this delectable stromboli. If you have more time, you can make your own dough, and feel free to add seasonings to the mixture. 

You don’t need to be a champion in the kitchen to create the recipe. It’s easy and straightforward! This dish is great to include in your dinner or lunch rotations. 

Here’s the recipe.

12. Air fryer stuffed sweet banana peppers

Cooking food using an air fryer works like a charm. It’s plug-and-play and offers another crispy satisfaction on the finished product. That’s why I love these stuffed sweet banana peppers!

The recipe combines these key ingredients: sweet sausage, cream cheese, banana peppers, shredded cheddar. It takes less than 20 minutes to complete the dish, so it’s perfect for those who are on the go.  

Here’s the recipe.

13. Three-meat stuffed banana peppers

Among the banana pepper recipes in the list, these three-meat stuffed banana peppers are on my top list. 

The combination of Italian sausage, ground veal, and ground beef stuffed in the peppers gives a burst of exciting flavor to the recipe. Other ingredients such as tomato sauce, parmesan cheese, herbs, and spices go well with the meat. 

The best part? You can freeze them and eat them whenever you want!

Get the recipe here.

14. Two-pepper pasta salad

This pasta salad is made with sweet bell pepper, pickled peppers, onion, parsley, red wine vinegar-based dressing, and drizzled with a bit of extra olive oil. The result? A tangy yet palatable salad!

If you opt for an adventurous route, feel free to add those ingredients you want to include in the salad. 

More details about this salad here.

15. Mediterranean pasta salad

Banana pepper is one of the key players in concocting this Mediterranean pasta salad along with red bell pepper, cucumber, lemon juice, and orzo.

The inclusion of the lemon-based vinaigrette dressing and mini farfalle or orzo gives a party in your mouth. It’s a crowd-pleaser indeed! 

Get the recipe here.

The bottom line

Cooking with banana peppers isn’t that complicated as you might think as vegetables are versatile enough to go with other ingredients. In my experience, these peppers work great in my salsa and salad recipes. You should try it!

The next time you harvest plenty and don’t know what to do with it, then visit these creative recipes for banana peppers in my collection again.

Banana pepper recipes

Banana pepper recipes

This recipe guide features 15 of my best banana pepper recipes. From stuffed banana peppers to Mediterranean pasta salad, everything you need is here!

Ingredients

  • Stuffed banana peppers
  • Pickled banana peppers
  • Banana pepper ketchup
  • Hot sausage-stuffed banana peppers
  • Banana pepper and bacon hot dip
  • Banana pepper salsa
  • Fried banana peppers
  • Bacon and banana peppers grilled cheese
  • Stuffed banana pepper soup
  • Cheese stuffed banana peppers
  • Salami and banana pepper stromboli
  • Air fryer stuffed sweet banana peppers
  • Three-meat stuffed banana peppers
  • Two-pepper pasta salad
  • Mediterranean pasta salad

Instructions

  1. Gather your fresh banana peppers. 
  2. Choose a recipe in the list. 
  3. Create the dish and serve it at your family table.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

35 Greek recipes that should get you craving for more!
← Previous
What is pink lemonade?
Next →
Skip to Recipe