Skip to Content

25 BEST Pepper Jack Cheese Recipes (Spice Up Your Meals!)

25 BEST Pepper Jack Cheese Recipes (Spice Up Your Meals!)

Make these 25 crowd-pleasing pepper jack cheese recipes and spice up your meal routine!

When it comes to spice, I highly admire pepper jack cheese! 

And I bet you do too. 

Pepper jack is a semi-soft American cheese with a creamy and smooth texture. 

It may seem like fireworks of spicy flavors once you take a bite, but you’ll be surprised by its delicate buttery finish that will make you feel like wanting more. 

Pepper jack melts so nicely, which makes an excellent accompaniment for casseroles, pizza, nachos, mac & cheese, and even omelets! 

This cheese also goes well with veggies, olives, pickles, fruits, and jalapeno peppers. 

You can even make a fantastic spread with pepper jack and enjoy much more of your toasted bread and crackers. 

Pepper Jack Pimento Cheese and Pepper Jack Queso Dip are a personal favorite! 

And beat the winter with a warm bowl of Beef And Corn Casserole With Pepper Jack Cheese and Pepper Jack Potato Casserole

The kids would love the Pepper Jack Cookies and Pepper Jack Bites

Bet they’re going crazy with these treats. 

Moreover, Creamy Pepper Jack Pasta and Pepper Jack Crack Chicken are like music to my ears!  

They make me excited, and my mouth water. 

So if you want to bring your favorite dish to new heights or add an extra kick, trust that pepper jack cheese delivers.

Bring your regular cheesy bites to a new level by spicing them up with pepper jack cheese. 

These Pepper Jack Bites are much like an appetizer version of a pizza.

The oregano flakes give off a somewhat sweet and herbaceous flavor, while the panko bread crumbs help in providing light and crispy bites! 

Serve these treats with a warm marinara sauce, and enjoy! 

Ingredients include: oregano flakes, marinara sauce, flour, eggs, and panko bread crumbs.

You’ll get obsessed with this Creamy Pepper Jack Pasta recipe once you get a taste. 

The rich, tangy, creamy, and spicy flavors are to die for! 

The heavy cream is what makes the sauce thicker and richer. 

Meanwhile, the pepperoncini juice adds a nice tang to the sauce. 

And the secret to a super smooth sauce is constant whisking! 

Ingredients include: butter, heavy cream, pepper jack cheese, pasta, and pepperoncini juice. 

This dip will serve you in two ways–the cheesy goodness and the spice! 

The sauce gets creamier and luscious owing to the evaporated milk. 

So get the movie and nachos ready and indulge in this tasty dip! 

Ingredients include: butter, evaporated milk, diced onions, spices, and cornstarch.

Pepper Jack Broccoli With Bacon could be the ultimate side dish that everybody will love. 

Oh, the comfort that the aroma of pan-fried bacon and broccoli brings is so irresistible! 

Make the sauce thicker with the help of cornstarch

Ingredients include: cornstarch, pepper jack cheese, cream cheese, bacon, and fresh broccoli.

The name says it all, you can have the richest and creamiest version of mac and cheese with this ultimate pepper jack mac and cheese! 

The cream cheese provides a smooth and velvety texture, while sharp cheddar cheese gives off bold flavors. 

And pepper jack cheese got your back for that extra spice boost. 

Ingredients include: elbow macaroni, egg, cream cheese, butter, and mustard powder.

These Pepper Jack Potatoes will steal the spotlight on your serving table! 

It is a simple dish of mashed boiled potatoes covered with melted cheese and topped with cream. 

Pro tip: Adding vinegar to the boiling water will help the potatoes hold their shape. 

Ingredients include: cream, pepper jack cheese, potatoes, and salt.

Pepper Jack Potato Casserole can be your house’s newest favorite side dish! 

Bring this casserole over the top with excellent toppings like bacon, parmesan cheese, and Ritz crackers.

Make it ahead of time or freeze it for later; this casserole tastes amazingly wonderful. 

Ingredients include: hash browns, whip cream, bacon, Ritz crackers, and melted butter.

Ridiculously cheesy and tasty, these Pepper Jack Chicken Taquitos are bound for keeps. 

The chicken filling made of cheese and chipotle salsa mixture is wrapped in a crispy fried corn tortilla

Ingredients include: chicken breast, taco seasoning, cream cheese, corn tortillas, and jarred salsa.

This homemade Pepper Jack Pimento Cheese recipe is an excellent spread for your white bread, crackers, or pretzels. 

Best of all, a heaping of this remarkable spread on toasted bread is marvelous. 

Ingredients include: mayonnaise, cream cheese, pimentos, pepper jack cheese, and Worcestershire sauce.

Make your juicy and tender chicken much better with this Grilled Salsa Verde Pepper Jack Chicken recipe. 

The chicken absorbs the zest, tang, and heat of the salsa verde.

Meanwhile, the salt content of salsa keeps the protein moist. 

The melted cheese locks in all the flavors! 

Ingredients include: salsa verde, cumin, lime juice, chicken, and olive oil.

I know you love spicy quesadillas, so here’s one recipe: spicy chicken pepper jack quesadillas. 

The chicken and melted cheese fillings create a wonderful taste explosion. 

Then, top it with sour cream, guacamole, or slices of peppers.

Ingredients include: flour tortillas, chicken, jalapeno peppers, sea salt, and cheese.

What To Serve With Chicken Quesadillas

Bring your regular corn side dish up one notch with this Pepper Jack Corn Gratin recipe! 

The frozen corn and veggies bring heat and flavor to the dish! 

Either bake or broil the frozen goods; both methods yield a deep flavor and better texture! 

Ingredients include: frozen corn and bell peppers, shallot, butter, cheese, and whole milk.

Got picky eaters at home? 

This Veggie & Pepper Jack Quesadillas With Cilantro-Lime Pesto would be a hit! 

The tangy and herbaceous flavor of pesto adds so much flavor! 

And if you like it spicy, a pinch of red pepper flakes or a small jalapeno to the pesto will do just fine. 

Ingredients include: raw almonds, cilantro, salt, tortillas, and salsa.

I am sure you’ll get addicted to this Pepper Jack Crack Chicken! 

Adore the mingling of pepper jack cheese’s mild heat and the cooling flavor that the ranch dressing brings. 

Not to mention the crispy bits of bacon! 

Ingredients include: chicken, bacon, ranch dressing, onions, and pepper jack cheese.

This hearty and tasty meal combines salsa, corn, cheese, and beef. 

The corn’s sweetness is a great filling addition, while the blend of salsa and cheese makes up a flavorful and spicy mixture. 

Tone down the spice with the help of sour cream

Ingredients include: ground beef, olive oil, white corn, jarred salsa, and sour cream.

I wager you’ll come back to this dish again and again. 

This Beef Burritos With Pepper Jack Cheese And Baked Beans will leave a good impression on your palate. 

The soft and creamy textures of black beans and corn kernels’ sweet buttery flavor are to die for! 

Ingredients include: sirloin beef, white rice, salsa, black beans, and green onions.

These Pepper Jack Cookies may look like a biscuit or cracker, but one thing’s for sure, these morsels are the best accompaniment to a warm, comforting bowl of soup. 

Cheesy, slightly spicy, and melt-in-your-mouth texture, these cookies could be the next star in your cheese tray. 

Ingredients include: butter, flour, garlic powder, pepper jack cheese, and salt.

Impress your friends with these melt-in-your-mouth bites of Pepper Jack Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms! 

The tomato paste brings in bold flavors, while the red bell pepper gives a tangy taste and a nice crunch. 

Juicy, plump, and delectable, you will love these luscious treats. 

Ingredients include: white mushrooms, red bell pepper, tomato paste, onions, and pepper jack cheese.

Get obsessed with these Pepper Jack Cheese And Herb Biscuits! 

The whipping cream is to blame for its flaky texture, and the pairing of herbs and spice of pepper jack cheese is such a surprise. 

So try it and let these treats comfort you with their cheesy and herby flavor.

Ingredients include: all-purpose flour, dried herbs, whipping cream, butter, and ground black pepper.

Prepare these delectable Turkey Pepper Jack Paninis in the blink of an eye! 

Light mayo, dijon mustard, and a squirt of hot sauce make up a sandwich spread that gives off a nice kick! 

Add some fixings such as lettuce, tomato, or fresh fruit. 

Ingredients include: buns, turkey slices, hot sauce, Dijon mustard, and pepper jack cheese.

10 Minute Turkey Pepper Jack Paninis

This Jalapeno Pepper Jack Turkey Burger recipe will satisfy your cravings for big flavors! 

Take a bite and get a whole new experience of a spicy, juicy, and moist turkey burger. 

The onions and garlic add moisture and taste, while Worcestershire adds exceptional flavors.

So divine and crazy flavorful–everybody will rave about it! 

Ingredients include: smoked paprika, cumin, egg, ground turkey, and cilantro.

Beat the cold wintry days with this pepper jack potato soup! 

The chunks of semi-mashed potatoes add more texture to the dish. 

Then blend with the melted cheese mixture, and you’ll get super thick soup! 

Remember to add salt and pepper to taste and top with bacon. 

Just because bacon makes everything better!

Ingredients include: potatoes, celery, sour cream, bacon, and milk.

Bacon and potatoes are an excellent pair too! 

Incorporate them into a soup, and you’ll get a hearty meal for the family. 

The blend of chicken broth, flour, and milk makes a creamy base for the soup, while the freshly grated pepper jack cheese and bacon make it tastier and more flavorful! 

Ingredients include: chicken broth, whole milk, bacon, potatoes, and bacon. 

Adore the festive layers of seasonings in this Chicken Fajita And Rice Soup from smoked paprika, garlic, cumin, and chili that perfectly blend with the enchilada sauce. 

I bet you’ll beg for more after each spoonful. 

Not to mention the velvety cheese soup smothered with tons of pepper jack cheese! 

And, of course, the abundance of textures and flavors.

Ingredients include: chicken thighs, black beans, long-grain rice, bell pepper, and green chilies. 

Prevent your guests from getting hungry with this comforting cheesy hominy casserole! 

This dish contains sour cream, peppers, hominy, and cheese. 

Get the fresh corn flavor from hominy and an almost smoky and earthy taste from the ground cumin.

And if you want to add some spice, cayenne pepper will do the trick. 

Ingredients include: hominy, ground cumin, cayenne pepper, sour cream, and panko bread crumbs.

The bottom line

And there you have it! 

If you want to spice up your dishes a little, you can count on pepper jack cheese. 

May it be hearty burgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, or slather some dip to your favorite toasted bread. 

You may also slice or cut them into cubes and set them on a cheese platter together with your crackers and bread. 

Well, what else to love about pepper jack cheese?


25 BEST Pepper Jack Cheese Recipes

25 BEST Pepper Jack Cheese Recipes

Make these 25 crowd-pleasing pepper jack cheese recipes and spice up your meal routine!


  • Pepper Jack Bites
  • Creamy Pepper Jack Pasta
  • Pepper Jack Queso Dip
  • Pepper Jack Broccoli With Bacon
  • Ultimate Pepper Jack Mac And Cheese
  • Pepper Jack Potatoes
  • Pepper Jack Potato Casserole
  • Pepper Jack Chicken Taquitos
  • Pepper Jack Pimento Cheese
  • Grilled Salsa Verde Pepper Jack Chicken
  • Spicy Chicken Pepper Jack Quesadillas
  • Pepper Jack Corn Gratin
  • Veggie & Pepper Jack Quesadillas With Cilantro-Lime Pesto
  • Pepper Jack Crack Chicken
  • Beef And Corn Casserole With Pepper Jack Cheese
  • Beef Burritos With Pepper Jack Cheese And Baked Beans
  • Pepper Jack Cookies
  • Pepper Jack Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms
  • Pepper Jack Cheese And Herb Biscuits
  • Turkey Pepper Jack Paninis
  • Jalapeno Pepper Jack Turkey Burgers
  • Pepper Jack Potato Soup
  • Pepper Jack Potato And Bacon Soup
  • Chicken Fajita And Rice Soup
  • Cheesy Hominy Casserole


  1. Scroll for your favorite recipe from our list of Pepper Jack Cheese Recipes.
  2. Pick out the ingredients needed for the chosen dish.
  3. Cook then enjoy immediately!

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe