If you’re looking for unique and creative ice cream cake recipes, you’ve come to the right place. From a holiday peppermint flavor to a refreshing summer taste, we rounded up thirteen of the best-layered cake ice cream recipes for you to enjoy!
Whether it’s for a birthday party, holiday party, or just because you love ice cream cake, this collection of recipes from Black Forest Ice Cream Cake to Caramel Apple Crunch Ice Cream Cake will surely inspire you to make an incredible ice cream cake that everyone will love.
This list includes ice cream cake with a cake base, ice cream birthday cake recipes, and so much more.
Look forward to #11 too!
1. Giant Cookie Sandwich
This ice cream cake looks, and is, a giant chipwich!
This ice cream cake is easy to make since it isn’t layered.
You need to bake two massive cookies and stick some creamy vanilla ice cream in between them.
The giant cookie sandwich is sure to be a hit, and people will find it hilarious until they take a bite and fall into a pit of deliciousness.
Don’t overthink your ice cream cake; go for this simple-to-make chipwich for giants if it is intimidating you.
If you’ve never experienced the decadence of a black forest cake, this is your chance.
This Black Forest ice cream cake combines classic flavors of chocolate and cherry stacked between fluffy buttermilk cake layers.
Don’t miss out on this explosion of rich flavors ideal for a cold winter night or a festive holiday party.
This stunning Neapolitan layered cake is possibly the best-layered ice cream recipe on this list.
The ice cream cake with cake base hits all the flavor notes of Neapolitan ice cream but becomes more decadent with the chocolate cake base, so you get the best of both cake worlds.
If you can’t settle on a single cake flavor, now you don’t have to because the classic combination of chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla makes for a layered ice cream cake everyone will be fawning over.
This Orange Creamsicle cake is the perfect layered ice cream cake recipe for the summer months.
The flavor will have you hear the ice cream truck song in your head and transport you back to simpler times.
And the recipe can be a hit at a birthday party or a cold, refreshing treat for your whole family to enjoy.
This colorful cake is one of the best ice cream birthday cake recipes because of its dazzling appearance.
The recipe uses a yellow cake base and an entire rainbow of colors for an eye-catching result.
You can get creative with how you decorate the top, whether you want to go for rainbow sprinkles to up the color factor or slice some elegant strawberries to put on top; there are a million directions you can go with this fun cake.
I think everyone can agree that Cinnamon Toast Crunch is one of the yummiest cereals, so of course, it would be amazing in ice cream cake form.
The cake crust is crushed cereal for an added burst of cinnamon flavor.
This ice cream cake is a great way to surprise a kid if this is their favorite cereal!
Whether it’s a birthday or just a surprise treat, the Cinnamon Toast Crunch cake is sure to become a highly-requested dessert in your home once you introduce it to your family and friends.
It has an irresistible combination of sweet cinnamon cereal and creamy ice cream.
This triple berry vanilla cake is perfect for a refreshing and light summer treat.
The layered ice cream cake recipe calls for blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries, but feel free to use any combination of berries or use all the berries!
For those with a palette that doesn’t favor overly sugary desserts, this humble cake offers the perfect amount of sweetness balanced by the refreshing, natural flavors of the berries.
Some ice cream cakes are mostly ice cream or mostly cake.
But this ice cream birthday cake recipe lands right in the middle with the perfect balance of cake and cream.
This Funfetti ice cream cake looks like a classic white birthday cake but has a layer of ice cream squished between two cake layers for a cold, creamy surprise.
The aesthetic of this cake is satisfying with its pure white frosting and light, fluffy cake, but it gives that birthday vibe everyone wants with the fun sprinkles baked right in.
This cake is the whole package; it doesn’t get better than this delicious mess.
Who doesn’t love a toasted marshmallow smashed between a chocolate bar and crunchy graham cracker?
Well, if you love an old-fashioned s’more, you will fall in love with this S’mores ice cream cake.
The cake features homemade toasted marshmallow coconut ice cream, so we’re off to a fantastic start.
The addition of hot fudge, graham cracker crust, and topped with extra toasted marshmallows only completes the dish for the perfect gooey bite of s’mores.
I hope you don’t mind eating a little mess!
Strawberry milkshake is a simple but delicious dessert, and now you can eat it in cake form.
The cake is simultaneously light and decadent with a punch of strawberry, rounded out with fluffy whip cream and sweet ice cream.
If you have someone in your life that loves strawberry milkshakes, consider this for their next birthday or special occasion.
Perfect for a holiday party or family winter treat, the Peppermint ice cream cake takes peppermint’s sweet and refreshing flavor.
It pairs it with a drizzle of chocolate syrup and a rich chocolate cake base.
Best of all, it comes out in a cute, charming shade of peppermint pink that will stand out on the dessert table.
Peppermint is a delicious holiday flavor, but this cake is super versatile and can be made in rocky road, vanilla, or mint chip flavoring if it just isn’t your thing.
Whatever flavor floats your boat, this cake can do it!
If you want a super-rich chocolate ice cream cake, this brownie ice cream cake is a scrumptious recipe that won’t leave you wanting anything.
The chewy bottom layer of brownie mimics an ice cream cake with a cake base, but instead, you get an ooey-gooey chunk of brownie.
For kids and adults alike, this brownie ice cream cake is a delightful combination of flavors that resembles a hot fudge brownie sundae, all wrapped up in a neat piece of cake.
The flavor of a caramel apple is unbeatable, but trying to fit your mouth around the hard, sticky caramel to get a decent bite into the apple can be rather challenging.
With this ice cream cake, you can experience the warm fall flavors of a caramel apple without struggling with that treat on a stick.
Brown sugar, cinnamon, caramel, and crunchy granola bars come together to form a unique flavor.
You can simplify the taste a bit by using vanilla ice cream, or you can kick up the autumn spice by using cinnamon ice cream!
The bottom line
This list has some of the best and most creative ice cream cake recipes, from light, refreshing ice cream cakes to decadent, chocolate recipes.
If you want to impress your family and friends with your baking skills but don’t want to do all that much baking, give one of these incredible and delicious ice cream cake recipes a whirl.
But if you’re feeling like trying another version of cake, why not make some poke cake for your loved ones!
13 Ways To Make Ice Cream Cake
Are you looking for the best cake to serve your guests? Here are 13 Ice Cream Cake Recipes that your friends will thank you for!
- Giant Cookie Sandwich
- Black Forest Ice Cream Cake
- Neapolitan Ice Cream Cake
- Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream Cake
- Rainbow Layered Ice Cream Cake
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch Ice Cream Cake
- Triple Berry Vanilla Ice Cream Cake
- Funfetti Ice Cream Birthday Cake
- S'mores Ice Cream Cake
- Strawberry Milkshake Ice Cream Cake
- Peppermint Ice Cream Cake
- Brownie Ice Cream Cake
- Caramel Apple Crunch Ice Cream Cake
- Choose your favorite recipe from our list of ice cream cake recipes!
- Turn it into a fantastic home-cooked meal!
- Leave a comment on our Facebook page and share your new dish.