Skip to Content

12 Cream Pie Recipes Filled With Fluffy, Gooey Goodness!

Have you been on the lookout for one or two cream pie recipes that will satisfy your sweet tooth with a velvety smooth, creamy-dreamy filling? 

Your search stops with this list of some of the most delicious cream pie recipes you’ve yet to discover. 

With recipes taking as little as 15 minutes, this collection has a pie for every level of skill and time commitment. 

The classic cream pie is a crowd-pleasing dessert staple that everyone loves. 

The richness of a creamy filling combined with a light and flaky crust makes for a sweet ending to a holiday meal or a neighborhood potluck.

This style of pie gets its name from the consistency of the filling whether it be custard, cream, or whipped-topping based.

Cream pies can be fairly complicated or extremely simple, with some even falling into the no-bake category.

With recipes taking as little as 15 minutes, this list has a pie for every level of skill and time commitment. 

From the luscious No-Bake Peanut Butter Cream Pie to the tropical delight of Creamy Classic Millionaire Pie and the easy-as-pie, nutty Pecan Cream Pie, you’re going to roll over and die for the simple sweet nostalgia of the dreamy cream pie recipes listed here!

There’s a wide variety of cream pie flavors to choose from, and if you look hard enough, you can find some unusual cream pie recipes to tempt your tastebuds with fresh new taste dimensions.

If you didn’t already have a favorite cream pie recipe, you’re sure to find one that tickles your dessert fancy in this collection of some of the best cream pie recipes around.

This thick and creamy homemade pie is well worth the wait. 

The flaky crust and toasted coconut give delicious texture to elevate this dessert to the next level. 

A whipped cream cloud topper perfectly complements the intense coconut flavor.

You won’t be disappointed in this vanilla cream pie recipe with a twist.

The tangy cherries are a perfect pairing with the vanilla and almond flavors of the cream filling.

Impress your family with this fresh combination for a tasty treat at your next gathering.

Chocolate lovers rejoice with one of the best cream pie recipes out there for fans of the magnificent cocoa bean!

Indulge in this decadent creation that combines layer upon layer of all the chocolate things you love in a single dessert experience.

An oreo crust filled with a chocolate pudding topped with whipped cream and chocolate curls checks all the boxes for a decadent treat.

If you seek unusual cream pie recipes, this elderberry version is something you don’t come across every day. 

Elderberry preserves and elderberry syrup infuse this tasty pie with an intense fruity flavor that balances the sweetness to perfection.

This pie gets its unusual look by using (clean!) bubble wrap to give it a honeycomb effect on the top of the cream filling.

For a mouthful of buttery goodness, bake up this classic sugar cream pie that was declared the official pie of the state of Indiana.

This simple but delicious buttercream pie recipe has only six ingredients in the filling to make for a quick 30-minute preparation.

A broiled buttery cinnamon topping is the crowning glory of this traditional midwestern dessert.

When you’re in the mood to make a cream pie recipe from scratch, you get to decide if this one is the world’s best!

The crunchy Nutter Butter cookie crust cradles layers of sliced bananas, thick custard, and whipped cream with a chocolate curl garnish.

This recipe’s textures and flavors meld together beautifully for a tasty twist on this cream pie standard.

This luscious addition to the creamy pie list gets its name because everyone that takes a bite says it tastes like a million bucks.

Combine the tropical flavors of pineapple, banana, and coconut float with fluffy cream cheese and Cool Whip filling for a no-bake summer delight.

Top it off with some colorful maraschino cherries for a festive addition to your next barbeque or picnic. 

When you’re looking for a cream pie dessert idea, the easiest recipe can turn out to be the treasure you’ve been hunting.

You can’t go wrong with cinnamon sugar-coated apples surrounded by heavy cream to please even the choosiest pie lover.

The large slices of fruit lend a hearty bite to this old-fashioned favorite, also known as German Apple Pie.

What better accompaniment to the signature southern pecan than cream cheese and whipping cream filling?

This easy no-bake recipe is a piece of cake, or should I say pie!

It’s best to make this one well in advance, as it needs eight hours in the fridge before it’s ready to serve and enjoy.

You’ll love this contest-winning tart dessert with a velvety lemon and sour cream custard filling that will have you going back for another slice.

In less than an hour, you can have this simple dessert in the fridge to chill and set. 

It’s a light summer treat that keeps you from heating up the kitchen for long.

As a lover of all things peanut butter, it was hard to pick a recipe that looked creamy, packed with peanut butter to the max, AND easy. 

But I think this is the one. 

No delusions of grandeur, just a powerful peanut punch-up of flavor in a thick no-bake crust, a creamy-dreamy cream cheese filling, easy Cool Whip, and a nice swoosh of chocolate glaze on top to break up the nuttiness (if you want it).

A warm-weather take on a holiday classic, this no-bake pumpkin pie is ready to chill in a flash.

It only takes 15 minutes to mix 5 simple ingredients to fill a pre-made graham cracker crust. 

Pop it in the fridge to chill after lunch for an after-dinner indulgence.

There’s a lot of cream pie recipe goodness out there to inspire your next dessert.

Even if you’re short on time, it’s possible to put together a delicious pie that will be a welcome addition to your next event or a special treat for the ones you love.

Save yourself some work in the kitchen by using a premade crust or refrigerated pie dough. 

No one has to know!

And don’t be afraid to try your hand at something new or improve upon an old favorite.

Whether you go for a classic flavor like banana or the more unexpected taste of elderberry, your next bake is sure to be a hit.

If you just need more pie, here’s our list of mini pie recipes!

12 Ways To Make Gooey Cream Pie

12 Ways To Make Gooey Cream Pie

You’re going to be wowed by this nice list of cream pie recipes when you are looking for dessert inspiration!

Ingredients

  • Homemade Coconut Cream Pie
  • Cherry-Vanilla Cream Pie
  • Chocolate Cream Pie
  • Elderberry Honeycomb Cream Pie
  • Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie Recipe
  • World’s Best Banana Cream Pie
  • Creamy Classic Millionaire Pie
  • The EASIEST Apple Cream Pie
  • Pecan Cream Pie
  • Sour Cream-Lemon Pie
  • No-Bake Peanut Butter Cream Pie
  • Pumpkin Cream Pie

Instructions

  1. Follow your sweet tooth to this list of cream pie recipes!
  2. Pick your favorite and wow your guests!
  3. Enjoy with friends and share on our Facebook!

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe