Are you looking for a truly fun and festive Thanksgiving treat? If you are, you are gonna love this simple turkey brownies recipe. These are fun and include a straightforward assembly process. We recommend that you start with pre-made brownies to make it even easier. These are so easy to make and are kid-friendly. Gather the kids and have them help you put together these turkey brownies. You’ll be surprised how simple it is!
Are you ready to get your gobble on? Gather everyone around, and let’s make some tasty turkey treats! Remember, it’s not just about the end result but the fun you’ll have along the way.
Tips for making this recipe
About the brownies – You can either buy a pan of pre-made brownies from the store or you can make the brownies ahead of time. If you get the brownies from the store, I advise getting them without icing. I find that tricky to find, so making them ahead is generally the best bet.
Plan ahead – This is a fun treat to make with kids. If you will make it with kiddos, you may want to cut the M&M pieces in advance. Also, depending on the age, cutting the brownie circles in advance may be better.
How to make Turkey Brownies
Ingredients
- Pre-made brownies
- Can of chocolate frosting
- 10 Nutter Butter Cookies
- 1 package M&Ms
- 1 package candy corns
- 20 candy eyeballs
Step-By-Step
Step 1: Make your brownies in advance. Whenever you choose to make the brownies, make sure that they are completely cooled before moving to the next step.
Step 2: Cut ten red, yellow, and orange M&Ms in half.
Step 3: Using a 3-inch round cutter, cut out ten circles from the brownies. Now, if you don’t happen to have a round cutter that is specifically for this purpose or the exact right size, just find something that you can use. Keep in mind that you want something that will not cut too large or too small of a circle. For example, the average mason jar has an opening of roughly 2.75” and while this isn’t exact, it is really close.
Step 4: Flip each brownie circle upside down so you can frost the smooth bottom. This step isn’t required, but it helps the cookie and decorations sit on the brownie a bit better.
Step 5: Frost each brownie with a thin layer of chocolate frosting.
Step 6: Use a small amount of icing to attach the candy eyes to each Nutter Butter cookie.
Step 7: Add a small amount of frosting to attach an M&M half below the eyes to complete the turkey’s face.
Step 8: Place a Nutter Butter cookie in the center of each brownie, about halfway down, leaving room at the top for the candy corn feathers.
Step 9: Press six candy corns into each brownie around the top to create the turkey feathers.
Turkey Brownies
These adorable Turkey Brownies are a fun, no-bake treat perfect for Thanksgiving! Made with Nutter Butter cookies, M&Ms, and candy corns, these festive brownies are easy to assemble and sure to be a hit at any holiday gathering.
Ingredients
- 1 9 x 13 pan premade brownies
- 1 tub premade chocolate frosting
- 10 Nutter Butter Cookies
- 1 package M&Ms
- 1 package candy corns
- 20 candy eyeballs
Instructions
- If you prefer, you can bake the brownies. We like using pre-made brownies for a quick and simple assembly. To bake, line a 9 x 13-inch baking pan with parchment paper and bake brownies according to the package instructions. Allow them to cool completely before removing from the pan. If using pre-made brownies, skip to step 2.
- Using a 3-inch round cutter, cut out ten circles from the brownies.
- Flip each brownie circle upside down so you can frost the smooth bottom.
- Frost each brownie with a thin layer of chocolate frosting.
- Place a Nutter Butter cookie in the center of each brownie, about halfway down, leaving room at the top for the candy corn feathers.
- Cut ten red, yellow, and orange M&Ms in half.
- Use a small amount of icing to attach the candy eyes to each Nutter Butter cookie.
- Add a small amount of frosting to attach an M&M half below the eyes to complete the turkey's face.
- Press six candy corns into each brownie around the top to create the turkey feathers.
- Enjoy!
Notes
You can swap out the Nutter Butter cookies with any similar peanut butter cookie if desired. You will need a 3” circle cutter such as a cookie cutter that is round for this recipe.