Skip to Content

14 No-Fuss Pudding Shot Recipes To Complete Your Celebration!

14 No-Fuss Pudding Shot Recipes To Complete Your Celebration!

Are you trying to find the best pudding shot recipes? We’ve rounded up 14 of our favorite pudding shot recipe ideas that will surely inspire you to create one soon. The only question is which pudding shot recipe you will choose to recreate first?

Pudding shot recipes are everywhere online and are a common dessert cocktail served best at the end of a great meal. 

These mini boozy desserts, such as the delicious Dirty Girl Scout Cookie Pudding Shot and Candy Cane Pudding Shot are perfect for any dinner party. 

There are plenty of variations and recipes online like festive #12, but we have narrowed it down to 14 easy to make and taste great recipes. 

Continue reading for inspiration on creating the best pudding shot flavors!

Perfect for summer, these pina colada pudding shots should be the staple of your next summer get-together. 

You will need a coconut cream Jell-O pudding box, cold milk, pineapple rum, malibu rum, pineapple juice, and cool whip. 

Serve the pudding Jello shots in small cups and garnish with an orange wedge and a maraschino cherry for a cool island feel. 

And the bright colors add style!

White Russians are standard creamy drinks. 

This pudding shot version is sure to be any white Russian fan’s favorite. 

You will only need four ingredients, wherein you can add in chocolate instant pudding mix, Kahlua, vodka, and cool whip. 

Let this pudding shot chill for a few hours and serve in a fun glass like a martini glass or mini shooter glasses for the ultimate entertaining dessert.

Are you looking for an easy holiday-themed dessert? 

Look no further! 

The eggnog pudding shot is the perfect recipe for you. 

To create these fabulous holiday treats, you will need vanilla pudding mix, milk, spiced rum, nutmeg, and bourbon. 

Don’t forget to serve in a sleek-looking glass for the full effect!

Everyone has their favorite girl scout cookie, and thin mints are a popular choice by many. 

This recipe is reminiscent of the thin mint cookie, but it is just for adults! 

You will need instant chocolate pudding mix, chilled milk, vanilla vodka, Irish cream, creme de menthe liqueur, and extra creamy cool whip. 

This recipe requires many ingredients to get the perfect banana pudding outcome. 

However, don’t let the long list of ingredients deter you. 

It is still a fun and easy treat to make. 

Ingredients include milk, banana coconut rum, sweetened condensed milk, cream cheese, cool whip, toasted coconut, mini vanilla wafers, and instant banana pudding mix. 

Garnish with a vanilla wafer and whipped cream for the perfect look.

Margarita pudding Jello shots are an excellent choice for summertime fun instead of a frozen margarita. 

These use traditional Jell-O instead of pudding to achieve that vibrant green color, but the concept is different. 

Add together lime Jell-O gelatin, lime juice, silver tequila, and triple sec to get the perfect lime green margarita shot. 

Don’t forget to salt the rim!

If you like caramel apple martinis, then this is the dessert for you! 

Serve up this pudding shot as the perfect end to a fall meal. 

The recipe calls for instant vanilla pudding, milk, apple vodka, caramel, cool whip, and toffee bits to garnish.

Pumpkin pie pudding shots are perfect for the Thanksgiving dinner you’ve been dreading attending. 

Many people bring pumpkin pie, but not everyone gets alcohol-infused pumpkin pie shots! 

To make these pudding shots, you will need Jell-O pumpkin spice instant pudding, milk, Bailey’s pumpkin spice liqueur, pinnacle whipped vodka, and cool whip. 

These are great without a garnish, but crushed graham crackers are a great choice if you want to add one.

This pudding shot is relatively easy to make, and you only need five ingredients! 

To make these yummy shots, you will need milk, instant cheesecake pudding, raspberry pucker schnapps, vanilla schnapps, and cool whip. 

Add crushed graham crackers to garnish! 

Be sure to layer the flavors when you add them to your cups. 

This dessert is sure to be a crowd favorite with its delicate flavors and light boozy taste. 

These oatmeal cookie pudding shots taste just like the oatmeal cream pie you remember from childhood! 

All it takes is a few ingredients to recreate the adult version of this treat. 

Ingredients include white chocolate pudding, milk, damn hot liqueur, butter shots liqueur, kamora, and cool whip.

For this delicious and timeless recipe, you will need chocolate instant pudding mix, butterscotch or caramel instant pudding mix, milk, Rumchata, butterscotch schnapps, and cool whip. 

If you want an intense butterscotch taste, go with the butterscotch instant pudding. 

If you’d like a light butterscotch flavor, use the caramel instant pudding. 

Be sure to have a heath bar or toffee to add as your topping!

Another holiday-themed item on this list is these delicious and fun Christmas sugar cookie shots! 

To make these treats, you will need water, Knox unflavored gelatin, ice cubes, Bailey’s Irish cream liqueur, butterscotch schnapps, and triple sec. 

For the garnish, you will need Christmas sprinkles and whipped cream. 

Salted caramel is a classic dessert flavor combination. 

Now you can enjoy the sweet and salty mix in a pudding shot! 

This recipe uses sugar-free items and lower-fat milk, but you can substitute for full fat and sugar items if you like. 

You will need sugar-free butterscotch pudding mix, skim milk, salted caramel vodka, salted caramel Kahlua, fat-free whipped cream topping, and sprinkles to garnish. 

Fun candy cane-inspired pudding shots would definitely be a hit at any holiday party! 

You can also create it with a Jell-O pudding mix together with some milk and a cool whip. 

For alcohol, you will need creme de menthe or peppermint schnapps. 

Be sure to add layers with your mixes and top with candy canes before serving!

The bottom line

Pudding shots are excellent party treats. 

As with any cocktail-type treat, you can take out the alcohol for a delicious sober pudding shot if you like. 

Every recipe for pudding shot on this list is perfect for any time of year, though you may find that some are more seasonal shots. 

For instance, the eggnog pudding shot would be perfect for your next adult holiday party. 

Pudding shots are super easy to make. 

All you need to do is mix your alcohol, milk, and pudding mix until it is well combined. 

Then you separate the mixture into your serving cups and freeze overnight. 

Make one of these boozy sweet treats for your next gathering!

14 Pudding Shots

14 Pudding Shots

Searching for something fantastic to complete your celebration, look no further than these14 pudding shot recipes!


  • Pina Colada Pudding Shots
  • Chocolate White Russian Pudding Shot
  • Eggnog Pudding Shots
  • Dirty Girl Scout Cookie Pudding Shot
  • Banana Pudding Shots
  • Margarita Jell-O Shots
  • Caramel Apple Martini Pudding Shot
  • Pumpkin Pie Pudding Shot
  • Raspberry Cheesecake Pudding Shot
  • Oatmeal Cookie Pudding Shot
  • English Toffee Pudding Shot
  • Christmas Sugar Cookie Jell-O Shots
  • Salted Caramel Latte Pudding Shot
  • Candy Cane Pudding Shot


  1. Choose one or more options from our list of pudding shot recipes here!
  2. Create your new favorite dish.
  3. Pat yourself on the back for making food at home for you to enjoy!
  4. Share and comment! Did you make any tweaks so it’s all your own?

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe