Skip to Content

13 Best Butter Extract Recipes (Cakes, Cookies & More!)

13 Best Butter Extract Recipes (Cakes, Cookies & More!)

Here, we’ve gathered the best butter extract recipes you can make at home, along with helpful tips for using the ingredient and a homemade version.

Butter extract, a concentrated flavoring derived from butter, is a versatile and beloved ingredient in the world of culinary arts. A precise addition of this extract brings out the depth and complexity of flavors.  

While it may not be as commonly used as butter itself, it plays a crucial role in enhancing the flavor of various recipes, from cookies and cakes to sauces and gravies. 

If you’re new to this ingredient and planning to make a great recipe out of it, this list of tips and ideas will help you get started on the right track.

How To Make Homemade Butter Extract

Making butter extract can be a fun kitchen project. Here’s how you can make your own simple butter extract at home:

  • 1/2 c unsalted butter
  • 1 1/2 c vodka
  • Glass jar with tight lid
  • Coffee filter, cheesecloth


  • Melt butter. Over low heat, melt the butter without browning.
  • Combine. Mix slightly cooled butter with vodka.
  • Jar transfer. Pour mixture into jar and seal.
  • Daily shake. Shake the jar daily for a week.
  • Strain. After a week, strain out butter solids using a coffee filter or cheesecloth.
  • Store. Keep in a cool, dark place.

Best Butter Extract Recipes

1. Butter Flavor Sugar Cookies

These cookies have an added buttery taste from the butter-flavored extract, making them even tastier than classic sugar cookies. They have crispy edges and soft centers, staying chewy for days.

2. Buttery Coconut Oil Spread

This easy coconut oil spread is a dairy-free butter substitute. In just five minutes, with a few ingredients, you’ll have a creamy spread for toast, pancakes, and more.

3. Harry Potter Butterbeer

Harry Potter Butterbeer is a quick, creamy butterscotch drink inspired by the series. Just mix cream soda with butterscotch topping, caramel and butter extracts, and add whipped cream for a magical treat.

4. Kentucky Butter Cake

This Kentucky Butter Cake offers a buttery and sweet flavor in every bite. Coated with a sugary glaze, the rich cake has a crispy outer layer and a sweet, soft inside.

5. Yellow Layer Cake With Chocolate Buttercream

This dessert recipe involves making a tender yellow cake and layering it with a rich chocolate buttercream frosting. For a moist and fluffy cake, use room-temperature ingredients and avoid overmixing.

6. Butter Pecan Cookies

Butter Pecan Cookies are soft with a buttery, brown sugar taste and crunchy pecans. They’re made chewy with cornstarch, rolled in sugar, and topped with a pecan for a delicious look.

7. Butter Rum Muffins

Butter Rum Muffins are fluffy, moist breakfast treats made with buttermilk and butterscotch chips. They’re topped with a butter rum sauce for more flavor and moisture.

8. Buttermint Ice Cream

Buttermint Ice Cream is a delightful frozen dessert that tastes like the classic pastel-colored buttermints. It’s made from vanilla ice cream, butter and peppermint extracts, and white chocolate bits.

9. Butter Ice Cream

Butter Ice Cream is a luxuriously smooth and creamy dessert with a delightful sweet-salty balance, ideal for warm summer days. The recipe uses heavy cream, sugar, egg yolks, salt, and butter.

10. Chocolate Chip Cookies

This Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe is chewy and rich, made with shortening and butter plus butter extract. It blends semisweet and bittersweet chocolate chips for a cookie that’s perfectly balanced between sweet and bitter.

11. Vanilla Butter Cake

This Vanilla Butter Cake recipe is soft, moist, and full of buttery flavor. It can be easily dressed up or down with frosting, sprinkles, or other toppings.

12. Pound Cake With 5 Flavor Butter Glaze

This classic Southern dessert uses five extracts and a butter glaze for rich flavor. It’s a moist cake great for special occasions or everyday treats.

13. Snowman Sugar Cookies

These Snowman Sugar Cookies are a simple holiday treat. Just chill the dough, shape it into snowmen, bake, and then decorate with frosting and sprinkles for a fun, tasty cookie!

The bottom line

Butter extract isn’t only versatile but also specific in its applications. Whether for baking, frosting, sauces, popcorn, beverages, or candy making, its ability to impart a precise, buttery flavor makes it an invaluable and indispensable ingredient in today’s culinary world.

And when you happen to find yourself unsure of which recipe to create using this ingredient, feel free to return to this list of butter extract recipes for inspiration.

More About Butter

13 Best Butter Extract Recipes

13 Best Butter Extract Recipes

This list of the best butter extract recipes will inspire you to create delicious treats with rich, buttery flavors, from sugary cookies to decadent cakes.


  • Butter Flavor Sugar Cookies
  • Buttery Coconut Oil Spread
  • Harry Potter Butterbeer
  • Kentucky Butter Cake
  • Yellow Layer Cake With Chocolate Buttercream
  • Butter Pecan Cookies
  • Butter Rum Muffins
  • Buttermint Ice Cream
  • Butter Ice Cream
  • Chocolate Chip Cookies
  • Vanilla Butter Cake
  • Pound Cake With 5 Flavor Butter Glaze
  • Snowman Sugar Cookies


  1. Skim through our Butter Extract Recipes list.
  2. Select the recipe that looks good.
  3. Prep the ingredients as instructed.
  4. Be sure to share this list of foodie finds!

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe