Skip to Content

19 Dreamy American Cheese Recipes: Cheeseburgers & More!

19 Dreamy American Cheese Recipes: Cheeseburgers & More!

Enjoy this list of 19 American cheese recipes that ooze with cheesiness and creaminess, from crowd-pleasing nachos to gooey sandwiches. 

American cheese often gets a bad reputation because of what it tastes like when eaten on its own. 

It has a different texture than other cheeses, and it has a salty flavor. 

But even though it does not stand out on a cheese platter, it brings the right amount of cheesiness and creaminess to recipes that it is added to.  

It is mouthwatering in dishes because it makes for a perfect base for gooey sandwiches, creamy mac and cheese, and tasty dips. 

Nothing beats the feeling of eating a warm and cheesy dish when you’re craving comfort food, and this cheese turns them into a treat that will hug your taste buds. 

There are also two types of American cheeses that you can put in your recipes: white and yellow. 

The white American cheese is saltier, while the yellow one has a bit of tang in it. 

You can melt them into the right consistency and pour them into your favorite foods like burgers, eggs, potatoes, and pizza. 

If you have not tried this amazing cheese yet, or if you haven’t cooked with this ingredient added in, we’ve gathered 19 American cheese recipes that you can easily follow and try at home. 

Make sure to stop by #19–you’ll love it!

This homemade cheese sauce recipe can be paired with your favorite crunchy nachos. 

You no longer have to opt for store-bought ones as this sauce is cheesy, creamy, and only takes minutes to make. 

Plus, you get to decide how much cheese you put in it. 

This sauce is great for parties, taco night, movie night, game day, or when you are alone and need something to munch on. 

How to Reheat Nachos

Cheeseburger is a meal that you can eat for almost any occasion, and there are times that you may even find yourself craving it. 

They can be served as a weeknight dinner, a part of the Fourth of July menu, or lunch on the weekend. 

Cheeseburgers are a guaranteed crowd-pleaser, and you can up the ante by adding tasty American cheese. 

So fire up your grill and make these cheeseburgers for your next get-together.

Little delicious hot dogs wrapped in crusty crescent rolls make a decadent brunch or snack. 

These Pigs in a Blanket are perfect for parties or casual gatherings, and even children can’t get enough of them. 

The cheddar and American cheese added to them melt wonderfully when baked. 

Garnish the rolls with poppy seeds or sesame seeds to add a bit of a nutty flavor, and dress them up. 

Serve them with mustard, ketchup, Creole mayonnaise sauce, or a combination of mayonnaise and mustard.

The dinner is always a winner when you serve the classic Macaroni & Cheese. 

It is cheesy, full of flavor, filling, and creamy. 

This dish never ceases to satisfy, and you can tweak the recipe as much as you want.

Nothing is more comforting and satisfying than a hot and melty Grilled Cheese Sandwich. 

Grilled cheese and rich tomato soup are a combination made in heaven. 

It is a fantastic lunch recipe and is loved by everyone, even the pickiest of eaters.

The amazing cheese sauce transforms broccoli into a glorious dish. 

You can steam or boil the broccoli to retain its crisp texture and brighten its color. 

For the sauce, the American cheese is the star. 

It is thick, briny, and smooth. 

Add onion powder to give the dish a subtle onion flavor and cayenne pepper or hot sauce for a bit of heat. 

Philly cheesesteaks are a hearty meal filled with juicy and outstanding flavors. 

It features sliced ribeye steak, melty American cheese, and toppings on a toasted hoagie roll. 

With this recipe, you no longer have to go to a diner if you’re craving this dish, as you can make this at home.

These soft and fluffy eggs with cheese are gorgeous, with wavy curds filled with tremendous flavor.

This dish is easy to make, as it cooks a scrambled egg, but a slice of American cheese is added before it is ready. 

You can serve these eggs for breakfast or brunch, put them in a sandwich, or serve them with toasted white bread on the side.

Kujirai Ramen originated from a Japanese manga and has since become popular for its need for minimal ingredients and tastiness. 

The instant ramen noodles come out bouncy and are cooked in a luscious, rich, creamy, and cheesy sauce with egg, garlic, and green onions. 

If you love Japanese food or ramen, this recipe is perfect for you!

After preparing a Philly cheesesteak and there is an extra toasted hoagie, why not turn it into the next best thing?

This pizza recipe features a warm crust, rich dressing, and melted American cheese blend. 

Since this is a pizza, you can go crazy with the toppings and put as much as you like.

This ham and cheese sandwich recipe is jam-packed with amazing taste. 

With the combination of maple honey syrup and American cheese, the sandwich is salty, savory, and a bit sweet. 

This dish will be a hit at parties, get-togethers, and brunches with your friends. 

You can also make them for a delectable lunch or dinner.

This recipe is a fusion of pizza bread, pepperoni roll, and pepperoni bread.

It is a fantastic bread that will appeal to everyone, regardless of age. 

You can serve this as a snack, a light lunch, or an appetizer. 

This two-in-one sandwich will be your next favorite. 

It has the savory goodness of a BLT and a cheesy kick of a grilled sandwich. 

This recipe is filling and has a lot of incredible ingredients in one dish.

How To Make The Perfect BLT

This Southern classic is cheesy, creamy, and comforting. 

This dish is great when you want to take a break from eating meat. 

The recipe also incorporates fresh vegetables, leeks, crushed potato chips, and breadcrumbs. 

What makes this dish special is that you can make this a day in advance, and you can easily heat it on nights when you don’t want to cook.

This Chili Cheese Dog has everything that you love in a classic hotdog in a bun. 

The palate-pleasing combination of cheese, chili, and hotdogs cooked in a smoker for a smoky taste give it a satisfying twist. 

You can serve this dish with fries, potato chips, or onion rings. 

With sesame seeds and layers of ground beef and American cheese, this Cheeseburger Pie looks and tastes like a cheeseburger but with more filling. 

Your friends and family can share this pie, making for a no-fuss appetizer at parties and backyard barbecues. 

Serve this pie with creamy mashed potatoes or crispy French fries and milkshakes for a complete meal.

These Au Gratin Potatoes are an excellent side dish that originated from a restaurant in Chicago. 

The dish is loaded with potatoes, milk, cheese, and spices. 

Serve it with casserole or ramekins as an accompaniment to your meal.

There is nothing more quintessentially American than this Turkey & Cheese Sandwich. 

Although it is often made days after Thanksgiving to use the leftover turkey from the celebration, you can still prepare this sandwich any time of the year. 

It is hearty and filling, and it will leave you satisfied. 

Pair this with potato chips or French fries for your lunch.

Aside from its burgers, McDonald’s is also known for its egg and cheese muffin sandwich served for breakfast. 

Replicate the delicious dish in your home, and you won’t have to go out or order delivery again. 

To complete the McDonald’s fantasy, serve this muffin sandwich with hashbrowns and pair it with coffee or juice. 

The bottom line

American cheese is hardly anyone’s preferred cheese, but with the right recipes, you can use its flavors to the fullest. 

With the list of recipes available, you can choose which meal you’d want to use this unique cheese on.

19 Dreamy American Cheese Recipe Collection

19 Dreamy American Cheese Recipe Collection

Enjoy this list of 19 American cheese recipes that ooze with cheesiness and creaminess, from crowd-pleasing nachos to gooey sandwiches.


  • Nachos With Cheese Sauce
  • Classic Cheeseburger
  • Pigs In A Blanket With Cheese
  • Macaroni & Cheese
  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich
  • Broccoli & Cheese
  • Philly Cheesesteak
  • Scrambled Eggs With Cheese
  • Kujirai Ramen
  • Hoagie Pizza
  • Maple Honey Ham & American Cheese Sandwich
  • Pepperoni Bread
  • BLT Grilled Sandwich
  • Tuna Casserole
  • Smoked Chili Cheese Dog
  • Cheeseburger Pie
  • Au Gratin Potatoes
  • Grilled Turkey & Cheese Sandwich
  • Egg & Cheese English Muffin Sandwich


  1. Find your favorite recipe from our American Cheese Recipes list.
  2. Gather all the ingredients needed.
  3. Start making and make us proud!

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe