Skip to Content

13 Best Sicilian Cookie Recipes To Bake At Home

13 Best Sicilian Cookie Recipes To Bake At Home

Bring the taste of Sicily to your home with these best Sicilian cookie recipes we’ve found on the internet!

From the land of remarkable vineyards, architecture, island beaches, and cathedrals, let’s tour Sicily, Italy. 

Sicily is said to be the land of myths and maidens. 

Greek mythology says that it is in Sicily where Hades stole Persephone away from her mother, Demeter. 

From the story of Odysseus’ journey to Hephaestos’ iron works to protect the heroes and gods of the Trojan war, they said it all happened in Sicily. 

But that’s another story to tell. 

For now, let me bring you a taste of Sicily right at the comfort of your home. 

Did you know that Sicily has world-famous bread, even known for pistachios and almonds that you can turn into amazing cookies?

So here are some amazing Sicilian cookie recipes you should always have in your pocket. 

Have you ever seen S or X cookies? 

Give Sicilian S Cookies or X cookies a try. 

The seamless combination of orange and almonds is not to miss when it comes to traditional Sicilian cookies. 

Sicilian Orange Cookies With Glaze and Sicilian Wine Cookies will delight you. 

Go crazy with the sweetness overload from almonds and honey drizzle from Fasciatelle and Sicilian twists. 

And it may seem odd and different, but the flavors of ‘Mpanatigghi will surprise you. 

So come and let’s get our hands on these fabulous Sicilian cookie recipes

Facciamo cuocere.

Cuccidati is all about its delicious fillings of orange zest, orange marmalade, almonds, raisins, and figs. 

Not to mention the chocolate, honey, and cinnamon wrapped in a buttery dough. 

I bet you’ll fall in love from the first bite. 

Ingredients include: Raisins, figs, roasted almonds, orange marmalade, and cinnamon.

You’ll be amazed by the playful combination of almonds and lemon in this recipe.

The lemon sugar gives off a fragrant aroma and strong lemony flavor. 

And for a change, you can also try lemon zest sometimes. 

Meanwhile, the biggest secret of this recipe lies in the almond extract, so remember not to skip it. 

Ingredients include: Lemon, almond flour, granulated sugar, egg whites, and almond extract.

If you’ve been to a Sicilian party, you’ve probably known about S cookies already. 

An old recipe from generations ago, Sicilian S Cookies could be the fluffiest and lightest cookie you will ever taste. 

Enjoy these treats in the morning with a hot cup of chocolate or coffee

Ingredients include: Eggs, vanilla extract, baking powder, sugar, and unsalted butter.

A typical and famous dessert in Sicily, Genovesi Ericine Sicilian Cookies will give you everything you love about baked desserts: stuffed with custard and dusted with powdered sugar. 

Light, airy, delicate, and not too sweet, these cookies are perfect for your afternoon tea. 

Ingredients include: Cornstarch, unsalted butter, lemon zest, milk, and semolina flour.

Too cute, these Sicilian Chocolate-Meat Cookies got a small window to tempt you with their delectable fillings. 

It is a blend of ground beef, chocolate, and spices. 

Adding finely chopped candied fruits, nutmeg, and cinnamon yields a unique texture and flavor. 

Ingredients include: Whole almonds, ground beef, egg yolks, ground nutmeg, and powdered sugar.

So colorful, this Sicilian Cuddura will brighten up your cookie tray for Easter. 

These bites are made of biscuits and eggs, which you can elevate by adding colorful sprinkles and icing for appeal. 

You can create them in different shapes and sizes, like nests, bunnies, or bells.  

Well, pretty much anything you like. 

Ingredients include: Flour, vanilla essence, sugar, eggs, and sprinkles. 

If you are thinking about using your fresh oranges, give these Sicilian Orange Cookies With Glaze a shot. 

Make wonderful cookies out of fresh oranges. 

The coconut oil works beautifully, adding an excellent flavor profile and lighter texture to the cookies. 

Ingredients include: Sour cream, baking powder, palm sugar, oranges, and confectioner’s sugar.

These Sicilian Twists got great fillings like honey, almonds, and cinnamon. 

And they even get more delicious and tempting with drizzles of honey and sprinkles of toasted almonds. 

Pair them up with a cup of cappuccino for a cozy afternoon dessert. 

Ingredients include: Eggs, vanilla, lemon, honey, and cinnamon.

These little cookies with cross cuts are crisp and sweet. 

The distinct licorice and a bit of sweet flavor of anise pairs well with the vanilla extract, which greatly enhances the taste of the cookies. 

Give these bites a nice glaze made of vanilla, milk, and confectioners sugar. 

Ingredients include: Yeast, baking powder, anise seeds, vanilla extract, and shortening.

Not too sweet and has a slight crunch, this Sicilian Wine Cookie recipe will pique your interest. 

This dish calls for a small amount of wine, but the flavor won’t be pronounced. 

Instead, the wine adds complementary flavors to the cookies. 

The orange zest enhances the taste of cookies. 

Ingredients include: Granulated sugar, flour, baking powder, semi-sweet chocolate chips, and anise extract. 

Fasciatelle is sure to surprise! 

One of Sicily’s most popular cookies, Fasciatelle has wonderful fillings made of butter, sugar, almonds, and honey. 

From strips to twists, finish these morsels with some terrific honey drizzle and slices of almonds. 

Ingredients include: All purpose flour, sugar, baking powder, and eggs.

Let the kids help you in the kitchen as you make these Frosted Sicilian S Cookies. 

Adore the sweet and sugary glaze any time of the year. 

Whether you like almond or lemony flavor, both taste lovely. 

Ingredients include: Egg, lemon, baking powder, granulated sugar, and milk.

This recipe will surely excite you if you are onto pistachios, almonds, or chestnuts! 

An Italian take on macarons, these rolling balls look adorable when raw. 

Give these bites some decorative garnish to make them look appealing. 

Ingredients include: Flour, lemon, egg, pistachio, and sugar.

The bottom line

True enough, Sicily is beautifully rich and wonderfully made. 

With rich cultural heritage and traditions, Sicily is such a gem. 

From landmarks to dishes and cookies in particular. 

So for your sweet tooth, I am certain that you will fall in love with Sicilian cookies.

More Italian Cookies

13 BEST Sicilian Cookie Recipes

13 BEST Sicilian Cookie Recipes

Bring the taste of Sicily to your home with these best Sicilian cookie recipes we've found on the internet!


  • Sicilian Fig Cookies
  • Sicilian Almond Paste Cookies
  • Sicilian S Cookies
  • Genovesi Ericine Sicilian Cookies
  • 'Mpanatigghi (Sicilian Chocolate-Meat Cookies)
  • Sicilian Cuddura
  • Sicilian Orange Cookies With Glaze
  • Sicilian Twists
  • Sicilian Anise Cookies
  • Sicilian Wine Cookies
  • Fasciatelle
  • Frosted Sicilian S Cookies
  • Sicilian Pistachio Cookies


  1. Skim through our Sicilian Cookie Recipes list.
  2. Select the recipe that looks good.
  3. Prep the ingredients as instructed.
  4. Be sure to share this list of foodie finds!

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe