We’ve rounded up these 15 mouthwatering copycat Crumbl cookies recipes that re-create some of the beloved sweet treats on their menu.
Crumbl is a cookie brand that’s popular for its more than 200 cookie offerings.
Their menu is filled with cookie treats with diverse flavors and colorful appearances that took inspiration from various desserts.
They tend to switch menu items every week, which means that you’ll be served four to five different cookie flavors and variants weekly.
Sadly, many of your favorite cookies may not be available most of the time as they merely show up on their menu for a week.
Given this, many copycat Crumbl cookies recipes have been formulated to recreate cookies that are similar to those sold by Crumbl.
You can create some of these as party snacks or desserts for your loved ones or sell these cookies at a much lower cost than the original.
For instance, you could either create some colorful treats with the copycat Confetti Cake and Funfetti Cookies.
You might also want to try some copycat Crumbl chocolatey treats, like the decadent Copycat Oreo Crumbl Cookies.
If you’re curious about the possibilities of copycat Crumbl cookies and want to make one of these, you’ve come to the right list!
Below are 15 of the best copycat Crumbl cookies recipes you should try out for yourself.
1. Buttermilk Pancake Crumbl Cookie
First up, we have the copycat version of the Buttermilk Pancake Crumbl, which, at first glance, seems like a regular butter cookie with frosted cream on top.
However, this cookie treat has three main parts–the cookie itself, the buttermilk glaze, and the frosting on top.
Combining the soft and chewy cookie, the buttery glaze, and the creamy frosted topping makes this cookie more appealing and appetizing!
Carrot cakes are one of those delicacies that may be seen as a weird mish-mash ‘til you try it for yourself!
In this case, you could create a similar carrot cake recipe; instead, it’s a delicate cookie snack.
For this recipe, shredded carrots are mixed on the cookie dough, bringing a unique cookie appearance to every bite.
On top of this is a sweet-tangy cream cheese spread with cracked pecan nuts to provide another layer of flavor to this copycat Crumbl delicacy.
Get ready to twist and turn with these copycat cinnamon swirl Crumbl snacks!
The cookie dough, in this case, blends butter, vanilla, sugar, and cinnamon, bringing a complementary spicy-sweet taste to everyone’s tongues.
To make this cookie recipe eye-grabbing, a combination of cream cheese, butter, and cinnamon are added as swirled frostings below a brown sweet cinnamon topping.
Churros are classic finger snacks that consist of fried dough smothered in sugar and cinnamon powder.
Indeed, you can make these crispy churro snacks into a cookie too.
Top this cookie treat with a swirl of cinnamon buttercream frosting to make this more appealing and special.
Confetti cakes, also known as rainbow cakes, are famed party pastries that youngsters and elders will both love.
However, do you know that you could also recreate these confetti cakes as copycat Crumbl cookies?
In this recipe, confetti confectionaries, known as pastel quins, are smothered on the cookie dough and on top of the cream cheese frosting.
Having these pastel quins in these cookies literally provide more color to the butter cookie base.
You can also pick your preferred colored frosting, so get creative!
Cornbread is a classic Native American pastry made from cornmeal or powdered dried corn.
This copycat Crumbl cookie treat uses typical cornbread ingredients to make the cookie dough.
Add honey buttercream frosting and honey drizzle into the cookie, and you’ll have the perfect afternoon snack for you and your loved ones.
For those who don’t know, dulce de leche is a famed confection from Latin America and other countries that is basically caramelized milk.
Its brown color and thick consistency may not be evident, but dulce de leche is often made by stirring milk and sugar for some time.
Dulce de leche is often used in a wide array of bread, pastries, and confections.
Now, you could enjoy this sweet treat in your copycat Crumbl cookie too.
These cookies can already grab you by their appearance, especially with their alternating cream cheese and caramel swirls that bring a variety of flavors to every munch.
Can’t get enough of colorful cookie snacks?
Similar to the copycat Confetti Cake Crumbl, this Funfetti Crumbl uses a lot of colors, mainly brought by candy sprinkles mixed on the dough.
Depending on your liking, add as many sprinkles as you want to your cookies for a more eye-catching party snack.
Kids and adults alike will definitely want a taste of this copycat Funfetti Crumbl.
If you have ever traveled to New York, you know that aside from their famed attractions, there are also a lot of popular food items and dishes worth trying too.
For instance, you could try out their New York-style pizzas from many pizzerias in the State or the many food stalls that offer a wide array of regional dishes.
However, did you know that the great State of New York is also known for its cheesecakes?
Yes, they also have their brand of cheesecakes with a creamy and delicate cake texture with a chewy butter graham crust.
While having a piece of the classic NYC Cheesecake is great, you don’t need to force yourself to go there to have one.
Instead, try this copycat Crumbl cookie recipe inspired by the New York Cheesecake.
While not as soft as the original, these cookies retain much of the original Cheesecake, including the graham cracker dough and the cream cheese and vanilla frosting.
Oatmeal cookies are already a classic everyday snack.
However, you could step up the recipe based on the original Crumbl cookie with this copycat Oatmeal Crumbl treat.
Glaze every piece of these with a milk-sugar-vanilla mixture to complement the nutty and mild-tasting oatmeal in these cookies.
Oreo cookies are always a favorite due to their rich chocolate cookies and creamy vanilla filling.
However, if you want to experience more chocolatey goodness, you could try this copycat Crumbl cookie recipe using Oreo cookies.
The best thing about this is that you could also create towering frosted layers of crushed Oreo cookies and cream cheese, ensuring the best kind of sweetness that we deserve.
Sugary and minty is what this copycat Peppermint Bark Crumbl Cookie is all about.
A notable feature of this cookie treat is peppermint canes, a wildly popular mint candy, particularly among kids.
In this case, the crumbly chocolate cookie base is topped with cream cheese frosting and crushed peppermint cane, bringing a bit of crunch into this chewy cookie snack.
Add tarty spice to your sweet cheesecake cookie snack through this copycat Raspberry Cheesecake Crumbl.
This cookie recipe calls for a drizzle of raspberry jam on top of a butter graham cookie with cream cheese frosting.
Inspired by the actual Raspberry Cheesecake, these cookie treats will put a smile on everyone’s face.
Want some S’mores while you sing the classic C-A-M-P-F-I-R-E-S-O-N-G song from our dear friends at Bikini Bottom?
S’mores are marshmallow biscuits that are often prepared and consumed during camping trips, especially during campfires.
These usually involve toasted marshmallows and a layer of chocolate between two graham biscuits.
However, you could also create these copycat S’mores Crumbl by mixing small marshmallows into the dough.
You could add a marshmallow on top before baking it in your oven to achieve the kind of soft marshmallow chewiness that will remind you of the classic campfire treat.
Lastly, we have this unique copycat Chocolate Turtle Crumbl that takes the word “crumble” very literally.
Indeed, these cookies resemble turtle shells that, like these cookies, have a somewhat brittle appearance.
Not only is this cookie snack chewy, but adding pecan nuts to the mix also brings more bite into this treat.
For best results, you should add a drip of chocolate and caramel on top of the cookie.
The bottom line
There’s a reason why Crumbl is gaining much popularity nowadays.
Not only is that they have an active social media presence, but they also have a unique marketing strategy of selling a weekly rotation of cookie variants, making many of their unique Crumbl treats treasured snacks.
Because of the need for many popular Crumbl cookie variants, copycat Crumbl snacks are trendy.
These copycat cookies cost less than the actual products and also allow for more creativity from patrons!
Nonetheless, whether you’re buying the original or copycat cookies, it’s best if you share these cookies with your loved ones.
These delicious cookies are worth sharing as a breakfast meal, afternoon snack, or holiday delicacy!
Copycat Crumbl Cookies Recipe Collection
We've rounded up these 15 mouthwatering copycat Crumbl cookies recipes that re-create some of the beloved sweet treats on their menu.
- Buttermilk Pancake Crumbl Cookie
- Carrot Cake Crumbl Cookie
- Cinnamon Swirl Crumbl Cookie
- Churro Crumbl Cookie
- Confetti Cake Crumbl Cookie
- Cornbread Crumbl Cookie
- Dulce De Leche Crumbl Cookie
- Funfetti Crumbl Cookie
- New York Cheesecake Crumbl Cookie
- Oatmeal Crumbl Cookie
- Oreo Crumbl Cookie
- Peppermint Bark Crumbl Cookie
- Raspberry Cheesecake Crumbl Cookie
- S’mores Crumbl Cookie
- Chocolate Turtle Crumbl Cookie
- Pick one or more options from our list of Copycat Crumbl Cookies Recipes here!
- Start creating your new favorite cookie.
- Share and comment! Did you make any changes to make it even better?