We’ve rounded up 13 of the most tempting buttermilk cookie recipes, covering everything from classic favorites to more unique twists.
From filling oatmeal cookies to classic chocolate chip cookies, there are many ways to indulge in a sweet treat.
But if you’re looking for a new flavor to add to your baking repertoire—or just want something more unique and better than what you’re used to—then look no further.
As a cookie connoisseur, let me tell you one secret weapon in my kitchen arsenal: buttermilk.
And the reason is simple—buttermilk cookies are simply the best.
These decadent and tender treats encapsulate the perfect balance of flavor, texture, and sweetness.
Essentially, the acidity of buttermilk helps to activate the baking soda in a recipe.
When this happens, cookies and other baked goods come out of the oven tastier and just undeniably good.
So, if you haven’t explored the world of buttermilk cookies yet, now is the time to do so.
Whether you’re looking for something pure and simple or a little more adventurous, you will find a favorite buttermilk cookie recipe here.
Get ready for a cookie revolution with the buttery, fluffy goodness of buttermilk cookies!
#11 is an absolute must-try, so dig in and start bakin’.
1. Amish Buttermilk Cookies
Churning out a plate of these traditional Amish cookies is an easy way to transport yourself back in time.
Classic and slightly tangy, the simplicity of these cookies allows the buttery, melt-in-your-mouth relish to shine.
With an optional caramel glaze, these cookies are truly hard to resist.
We reach for this recipe when we’re craving a little nostalgia and comfort, and we know you’ll love it, too.
Though it’s hard to beat Amish buttermilk cookies’ simple, classic taste, there’s something extra special about these buttery treats.
There are no bells and whistles—these are just straight-up old-fashioned goodness, just like Grandma used to make.
With a light buttermilk flavor, these cookies will be devoured in no time.
And let’s not forget that the sugar and cinnamon-kissed topping make them a little extra special.
If you’re looking for that classic, wholesome taste of your childhood, this recipe is the one for you.
A little chocolate is always a good idea, which is why these decadent cookies are the right choice for an afternoon pick-me-up.
Using both cocoa and melted chocolate, the flavor of these cookies is delectable yet sophisticated.
And with a gooey, melty chocolate center, these cookies genuinely melt in your mouth.
Experience a full-on chocolate high with a plate of these cookies.
These tender and feathery vanilla cookies are at once delicate and rich.
Thanks to the light buttermilk flavor and a hint of vanilla, these cookies are beautifully balanced.
And with a touch of fine sea salt, these cookies will be your new go-to treat for any occasion.
Whether serving these as an afternoon treat or indulging in a midnight snack, you’re sure to find yourself returning to this recipe again and again.
These molasses-infused sweets bring a unique and spicy flavor to the table.
With a slight zingy touch of ginger, these cookies are a must-try for anyone who loves bold flavors.
I’m a massive fan of the über-soft texture of these treats, and you’re sure to be addicted too.
The glaze is melted meringue powder and powdered sugar, which gives the cookies a lovely sheen and helps them stay fresh for longer.
Baking up a batch of these cookies is an easy way to infuse your kitchen with the flavors of the holidays.
The frosting on these cookies is where the recipe really shines.
With a simple yet refreshing combination of powdered sugar, buttermilk, and vanilla extract, this glaze will have you licking your fingers and the bowl.
Of course, the cookies themselves are simply delicious too.
With the perfect amount of crispiness and softness, these cookies are ideal for pairing with a cup of hot tea or coffee.
All white and fluffy, these cookies make an elegant addition to any dessert table.
Adding a little zest to your favorite cookie recipe is a great way to liven things up.
These Gourmet Buttermilk Cookies are infused with a light lemony touch, which gives them an edge over the rest.
This recipe is a must-try for anyone who loves the combination of citrus flavors and buttery cookies.
There will be no crumbs left behind with these tempting delicacies.
Serve these with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a fun indulgence.
Here’s another take on buttermilk cookies with a subtle lemon twist, this time accented by almonds.
The combination of these two flavors is absolutely delectable and perfect for a bright spring or summer day.
Plus, the presence of chopped almonds on top adds an extra crunchy texture that’s sure to be a hit with sweet and savory lovers alike.
Your kitchen will be filled with the scent of freshly baked cookies with just one batch of these lemony delights.
The typical storage time for these cookies is about four days, but they’ll be devoured long before then!
And with almond and lemon extract in the frosting, there’s no going wrong when you try this recipe.
Two classic flavors come together in this recipe for the perfect dessert hybrid.
These cookies can only be described as decadent, with a liberal amount of chocolate chips and chewy oatmeal.
The buttermilk flavor is a little more subtle in this recipe, but it’s just enough to round out the flavors and give this cookie a little extra zing.
If you’re a chocoholic and a fan of anything oatmeal, you need to try this recipe as soon as possible.
They’re great for a bake sale, an after-school treat, or simply for a weekend indulgence.
No matter how you enjoy these cookies, they will surely be a hit with your friends and family.
Offering a unique and fruity twist on the traditional buttermilk cookie, these blueberry delights are an excellent way to surprise your taste buds.
If blueberries are your thing, you’ll love these cookies packed with plump and juicy fruit.
The buttermilk keeps the cookies soft and tender, which pairs perfectly with the sweet flavor of the blueberries.
You can add a dusting of confectioner’s sugar if you want to make them extra festive, or eat them as is for a simpler treat.
With just one batch of these cookies, your afternoon will surely be filled with sweet and satisfying goodness.
Chocolatey and nutty, these cookies have a delicious balance of flavors that’s hard to beat.
The chocolate chips paired with peanut butter chips are an excellent mix, offering the best of both worlds in one perfect bite.
Perfect for the fall season or a chilly winter day, these cookies will warm you right up and leave you satisfied.
We always keep a batch of these on hand for when the urge strikes.
The best way to eat them is warm and straight out of the oven, but they’re also very tasty at room temperature or even chilled.
Nutmeg is a magical spice that adds the perfect amount of warmth and sweetness to any cookie.
These nutmeg buttermilk cookies are no exception, and they’re a great way to dazzle your guests on any festive occasion.
With just the right combination of spices, these cookies are guaranteed to be a hit with everyone.
Let’s end this list with the classic buttermilk treat that started it all: the old-fashioned soft cookie.
These cookies are wonderfully soft and chewy, just like a good cookie should be.
There’s nothing fancy about them, but sometimes simple is best.
Or, if you want to try something different, you can add holiday-themed sprinkles on top for a festive touch.
The bottom line
Buttermilk is one of the most versatile ingredients in the kitchen, and it can be used to create a wide range of delicious cookies.
Most of these recipes are easy to make and don’t require too many ingredients, making them the perfect choice for any home baker.
You can add your preferred mix-ins to make the cookies even more special.
There’s no time to start baking some amazing buttermilk cookies like the present!
And when you’re done, your kitchen will be filled with the delicious aroma of sweet and satisfying goodness.
So get your mixing bowls out and start baking today.
Whip up a batch of one or more of these tempting buttermilk cookie recipes, and you’ll be the star of any occasion.
13 Best Buttermilk Cookie Recipe Collection
We've rounded up 13 of the most tempting buttermilk cookie recipes, covering everything from classic favorites to more unique twists.
- Amish Buttermilk Cookies
- Grandma's Buttermilk Cookies
- Melt-In-Your-Mouth Buttermilk Chocolate Cookies
- Vanilla Buttermilk Cookies
- Molasses Buttermilk Cookies
- Refreshing Iced Buttermilk Cookies
- Lemony Gourmet Buttermilk Cookies
- Lemon Buttermilk Cookies With Almond
- Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Buttermilk Cookies
- Blueberry Buttermilk Cookies
- Chocolate Buttermilk Cookies With Peanut Butter Chips
- Nutmeg Buttermilk Cookies
- Old Fashioned Buttermilk Soft Cookies
- Choose your favorite recipe from our list of Buttermilk Cookie Recipes!
- Wave your magic wand to make it your special recipe!
- Leave a comment on our Facebook page and share your new recipe.