This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Explore these Halloween Punch Recipes you can easily make at home, both nonalcoholic and spiked.
From Eyeball Punch to Apple Cider drinks, these fantastic Halloween Punch recipes are fun to concoct!
Pro Tips: If serving punch in a large bowl or carafe, remember to add any fizzy soda last since it will go flat after a few hours, and consider offering ice on the side so it doesn’t dilute the punch. Don’t forget the ice cubes that light up from the inside.
WANT TO SAVE THIS?
Don't lose this! Enter your email and we'll send it instantly.
1. Spicy Mulled Apple Cider
Warm, spiced, and easy to ladle out of the pot all night. Let the cinnamon and clove do the haunting, and add a splash of rum for the grown-up cauldron.
2. Halloween Eyeball Punch
The eyes have it! Canned lychees look remarkably like human eyeballs; add a few with blueberry “pupils” and it’s a creepy cocktail for sure. This recipe is nonalcoholic as is, but there are instructions for spiking, and for safe handling of dry ice that makes this punch super startling!
What we love about this recipe: Great steps and tips for finding and handling dry ice.
3. Creepy Cauldron Halloween Punch
Impress your guests with this Creepy Cauldron Halloween Punch. Made with berry vodka, raspberries, simple syrup, blackberries, and blueberries, this punch will turn a bland batch of cocktails into a work of art.
What we like about this recipe: A red wine foundation with liqueur makes for tons of flavor.
4. Witch’s Brew Halloween Punch
The Witch’s Brew Halloween Punch is a tangy mix of pineapple juice, ginger ale, lemon juice, and lime sherbet. In a delightfully repulsive green, it has chunks of sherbet that will certainly gross-out and thrill your guests. Add some dry ice to mimic a smoking cauldron for an extra spooky effect.
What we love about this recipe: Lots of citrus to offset the sweet sherbet.
5. Halloween Orange Sherbet Punch
Do you want a fun Halloween setup without the extra effort? Lots of sweet citrus flavor in this no-alcohol Halloween Orange Sherbet Punch.
What we love about this recipe: Tastes like Sunkist and an orangesicle had a baby and they named him Orange Julius.
6. Polyjuice Potion
Polyjuice Potion is another delicious way to enjoy a Halloween-themed party or movie night. Halloween is clearly the time of year when lime sherbet rules, because here’s another option for a green ghastly (but kid-friendly!) punch recipe.
What we love about this recipe: A whipped cream topping practically makes this a dessert.
7. Candy Corn Punch
This selection looks like candy corn instead of tasting like candy corn! 🍬🌽 This family-friendly drink is more reminiscent of a tropical popsicle with layers of mango and orange, perfect for themed Halloween and Thanksgiving celebrations.
What we love about this recipe: It’s pretty and doesn’t taste like candy corn! (Sorry, candy corn.)
8. Hocus Pocus Punch
Everyone loves a pop culture reference, especially during the holidays. What better way to celebrate Halloween than serving a punch named after a famous Halloween movie “Hocus Pocus.”
Made with apple cider, ginger ale, cranberry juice, and orange seltzer, this fruity mocktail can be enjoyed by the whole family.
What we love about this recipe: We love cranberry everything and this grown-up mocktail tastes like fall.
9. Sparkling Bourbon Pumpkin Apple Cider Punch
Sparkling Bourbon Pumpkin Apple Cider Punch is an incredible autumn-flavored drink. This beverage sings of apple and seasonal spices.
What we love about this recipe: Unique pumpkin-spiced apple cider, gentle bourbon, and a maple simple syrup
10. Spiced Pumpkin Punch
Take off the edge of the holiday stress by making a massive batch of Spiced Pumpkin Punch. The simple and festive recipe is made with champagne, apple cider, pumpkin puree, spiced rum, orange juice, and ground cinnamon.
What we love about this recipe: A showstopper taste and presentation in a pumpkin-style bowl and cups, plus the garnish of star anise, cranberries and cinnamon sticks.
11. Spooky Halloween Party Punch
I first saw a punch like this on TV a long time ago; Martha Stewart was on a talk show and I’ll never forget how it looked when the ice hands bobbled to the top of blood red punch.
Made with pineapple juice, a shot of vodka, and cranberry juice, this can be prepared in minutes, giving you plenty of time to enjoy the party.
What we love about this recipe: Creeper ice hands are creeper.
12. Pomegranate Ginger Punch
Pomegranate Ginger Punch is a goblin brew idea for a grown-up Halloween party. The deep red color of the punch gives off a spooky feel, and the bite of ginger tempers the sweet flavor.
What we love about this recipe: Everclear and ginger beer
13. Swamp Potion Punch
Swamp Potion Punch is a blended colada type of punch. Made with Cascade Ice, coconut milk, banana, green frosting, and sprinkles, this drink is creamy and delicious with fun themed rims.
What we love about this recipe: The opacity and tropical fruit-ness
14. Halloween Scorpion Venom Punch
Halloween Scorpion Venom Punch is one of the spookiest and most fun drinks, perfect for Halloween. The lemon Jell-O adds a bright color to this punch, including pineapple juice and vodka. This sweet drink will put the “sting” into your party.
What we love about this recipe: A 3-ingredient drink made with Jello. We’re in!
15. Halloween Blood Orange Blackberry Rum Punch
Serve your ghostly crew with this chilled Blood Orange Blackberry Rum Punch to complete the Halloween night of terror. Made with rum, blackberries, lime juice, and soda, this festive beverage will get you all in the party mood.
What we love about this recipe: No Halloween tricks here, all treats.
16. Blood Bag Spooky Halloween Punch
Do you want a creepy and creative way to serve a punch at a Halloween party? Why not have your guests drink it from an IV bag? The Blood Bag Spooky Halloween Punch is made with tequila, passion fruit, raspberry juice, coconut rum, and pineapple rum.
What we love about this recipe: When your cocktail wears a costume.
The bottom line
Halloween is not complete without a creepy, spooky, and delicious punch. From the mocktail to the cocktail, these punches will liven up any party, from the simple to sophisticated! In addition to the appetizers, sweets, and treats, you also need spooky drinks to set the mood.
Want even more ghoul-tastic Halloween Cocktails? Boo-tiful!
The blue drink with eyeball, how do I make this one? Can it be made non-alcoholic?
Here’s the eyeball drink: https://tipsybartender.com/recipe/the-skull-eyeball-cocktail (sub out the citrus vodka for a grapefruit or other citrus juice and sub the blue curacao for a bit of blue food coloring) and here’s eyeball jello shots: https://tipsybartender.com/recipe/halloween-eyeball-jello-shots (leave the vodka out for the gelatin shots to be non-alc)