Skip to Content

25 BEST Sugar-Free Pies 🥧

Here we are looking specifically at sugar free pies! When jumping on the sugar-free bandwagon, or at least the lower sugar caboose, it’s good to include a focus on desserts. 

As they say, it’s good to treat yo’self, even if it’s in moderation. 

Now a good number of pies have some fruit fillings of some kind, and fruit has a fair amount of naturally occurring sugar, so no added sugar is what we are after. 

Lots of people (like you, dear reader?) want to enjoy a “sweet” treat now and then. 

Check out this list of 25 sugar free pies to help you along!

It all begins with a sugar-free pie crust, so I have included some examples of crust recipes that could be used repeatedly. 

There are many sugar-free, easy pies to make, especially once baking with alternative sweeteners and flours becomes second nature. 

If sugar-free no-bake pies are the recipes you prefer, there are a few on this list, like #22! 

If personal-size Flaky Gluten Free & Keto Hand Pies are more practical, I found some lovely ones worth trying! 

I know back in the day, the quintessential Sugar-Free Jello Pie was perhaps one of the only options available, and the older set may like to revisit those options. 

What a time we live now with so many improved sugar substitutes readily available at our fingertips, whether in the grocery store or ordering online! 

Surely we deserve a treat now and then with tasty bites at the end of a meal!

May this list of 25 sugar-free pies inspire you on this sugar-free journey.

To start this list of sugar-free pies, I present this Sugar Free Blueberry Pie! 

Blueberries are the simplest of fruits to work with, needing nothing but a good rinse. 

You can use a pre-made crust, or instructions are given to make one. 

The filling is simply blueberries, Splenda, flour, and lemon juice, with the only sugar in the blueberries.

As with all fruit-based sugar-free pies, the only sugar comes from the fruit itself, in this case, the peaches. 

Free-stone varieties are your friends because they quickly come off the seed (or stone). 

The ingredients include Splenda or Stevia, tapioca pearls, and cinnamon. 

There is no crust but a topping of almond flour, butter, and brown sugar substitute.

Having a sugar-free pie crust recipe to pull out at any time is quite helpful, and I hope this one may become one of your oft-revisited recipes! 

This Coconut Flour Pie Crust could be used for either a sweet pie or a savory one!

This sugar-free pie recipe includes a press-in crust which using all almond flour keeps it low carb. 

The filling has a creamy, sweet-tart filling made of lemons, butter, eggs, monk fruit, or erythritol.  

The lemon curd part is made in stages through the microwave before combining with the cooled crust. 

It may not get any simpler than this recipe for sugar-free easy pies. 

This almond crust is made of almonds, butter, and Truvia. 

The chocolate cream pie filling is made of sugar-free instant chocolate pudding, skim milk, and heavy whipping cream. 

Mixing heavy whipping cream, cream cheese, and a sugar substitute makes a fluffy whipped topping! 

Here’s a list of even more sugar-free desserts that feature easy, peasy Jell-O!

This is an example of sugar-free no-bake pies that capitalize on using as many readily available sugar-free ingredients. 

Sometimes easy is what ya need! 

The ingredients used are:

  • Cream cheese
  • Splenda
  • Peanut butter
  • Sugar-free cool whip
  • Sugar-free chocolate syrup
  • Sugar-free peanut butter cups

The best tip is to keep it cold!

These adorable sugar-free hand pies feature raspberries as the filling. 

The crust comprises mozzarella, almond flour, cream cheese, erythritol, and an egg. 

The filling is raspberries and powdered erythritol. 

Roll out and cut the crust into squares, form the pies with filling inside and slits cut on top. 

Bake and enjoy!

Jello is featured next in these sugar-free Jello pies.

It uses the crust of your choice and multiple sugar-free Jello flavors of four different colors made up in four separate bowls with boiling water. 

Then they are mixed with cream cheese and need chilling for two hours before the pie can be assembled.

There is no added sugar in this sugar-free pie but the apples and juice have a lot of natural sugar. 

Start with a store-bought or homemade sugar-free pie crust. 

The filling is apples, apple juice, and cornstarch boiled and simmered together.

 Cinnamon and butter were added at the assembly stage.

I am changing things up a bit here with a random sugar free savory pie recipe! 

This is a crustless, keto, bacon, cheese, and tomato quiche. 

The best part is there are many variations allowable, from meats to veggies to cheeses. 

No need to bother with a crust, but you certainly can if you want to.

This vegan sugar free pie crust can be used with a sweet or savory pie creation! 

It is gluten, dairy, soy, nut, and refined sugar-free! 

The ingredients are sorghum flour, tapioca flour, salt, coconut oil, sugar-free sweetener, and water. 

Fabulous pictures and instructions!

An almond flour crust is a base for this sugar-free pie recipe for Coconut Cream Pie. 

There are a lot of ingredients and steps to follow, but thankfully there is a YouTube video you can watch ahead of time to be prepared and follow along with as you make your own.

Another cream-style sugar-free pie is coming up; this time, lemon is the flavor of choice! 

The crust is made with coconut flour. 

The filling uses Swerve and lemon liquid stevia, lemon juice, eggs, and sour cream. 

The topping is unflavored gelatin, heavy whipping cream, and liquid vanilla stevia.

Yum! Some more sugar-free desserts for you to make at home!

Here we have a bare-bones, sugar-free, no-bake pie recipe that uses only two ingredients. 

That’s right, and you guessed it, one ingredient is Jello! 

Jello and plain Greek yogurt are mixed between short warming spurts in the microwave for complete incorporation. 

No crust, no-bake; just chill for three hours and enjoy with a spoonful of whipped cream on top!

Gotta love it when a recipe gives ya options! 

This recipe for sugar-free hand pies has three variations: pumpkin spice mascarpone, orange, chocolate ricotta, or blackberry almond butter! 

The crust recipe is in an associated link. 

Video too!

As with any sugar-free pie like this Sugar-Free Sweet Potato Pie, a low-carb crust is the best way to start. 

Swerve is the alternative sweetener used along with the standard ingredients and seasonings. 

There is sugar in the sweet potatoes, but this recipe balances it out very nicely!

A delightfully light sugar-free pie of lemon ricotta is the perfect summer pie! 

The keto pie crust recipe is in an associated link. 

The filling is ricotta cheese, cream cheese, alternative sweetener, lemon juice, zest, and gelatin poured into the baked crust. 

Decorate with berries on top and refrigerate for several hours!

Sugar-free pies are eliminating the added sugar and making good swaps where consistency allows. 

Here graham crackers are part of the crust mix, but a keto-type crust would drop the overall sugars. 

The cream cheese, milk, and sugar-free instant pudding mix are blended. 

Then it is spooned into the crust, alternating with fresh-cut strawberries.

Tart pans with removable bottoms are recommended when making a sugar-free pie crust. 

This recipe is two-for-one with instructions and variations for a sweet and savory pie. 

They both use a combo of coconut and almond flour, and the sweet one uses liquid stevia.

A second brunch-type sugar-free savory pie recipe here is called the Five Onion Tart! 

Yes, the onions will need caramelizing, and there is an egg-based custard to make as well.  

But when it all comes together, a lovely sophisticated meal is ready! 

And yes, it uses the following five onions; yellow, green, shallots, yellow, and chives, along with lots of arugulas!

If you love Snickers bars and want to eat less sugar, this sugar-free, no-bake pie recipe is one you will love! 

This recipe has several parts, including the caramel, the crust, the filling, and the chocolate drizzle. 

Do take the time to read through the ingredients before starting, as there are a couple of alternative sweetener mixes to purchase or make.

Since this is a classic English tart, this sugar-free pie version must be as fit for a queen as the original! 

I love the use of cherries and raspberries with chia seeds. 

The four parts include the pie crust, the jam, the frangipane, and a topping.

Beautiful presentation and delicious too!

Who can resist that rich pecan pie at Thanksgiving Dinner? 

Nobody!

That is precisely why I searched high and low for sugar-free pies that could replicate that exquisite taste! 

Here a crust can be bought or made. 

The filling combines eggs, pecans, sugar-free syrup, and Splenda. 

Make one large pie or several smaller ones, and enjoy the last bite!

I could not overlook popular holiday sugar-free pies like this Pumpkin Pie! 

Everyone knows how a pumpkin pie tastes, so a sugar-free recipe has much to live up to, and allulose is the sweetener of choice! 

This recipe does a fantastic job, and it is decorated beautifully as well with maple leaf-shaped cookies!

I have saved the best for last to end this list of sugar-free pies! 

This Keto Key Lime Pie is my favorite from this list as its cool tanginess makes everything better! 

The substitutions are well thought out with an almond flour crust, and the whole pie is baked before being chilled for serving! 

Trust me, your friends and family will never know it is sugar-free!

The bottom line

You came to the right place when you were on the hunt for sugar-free pies! 

So many sugar-free pie crust recipes and everything from sugar-free no-bake pies to Jello pies are included! 

Happy sugar-free pie baking!

Top 25 BEST Sugar-Free Pies 🥧

Top 25 BEST Sugar-Free Pies 🥧

Let’s look at a hefty list of 25 easy sugar-free pies! You’ll love this selection of recipes that you can add to your lower-sugar dessert rotation.

Ingredients

  • Sugar Free Blueberry Pie
  • Sugar-Free Peach Cobbler
  • 4-Ingredient Keto Coconut Flour Pie Crust
  • Gluten-Free Lemon Curd Tart With Berries
  • Low Carb Sugar Free Chocolate Cream Pie
  • No-Bake Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Pie
  • Low Carb Keto Mini Raspberry Pies
  • Jello Cheesecake
  • Tried & True Sugar Free Apple Pie
  • Crustless Quiche
  • Gluten-Free Vegan Pie Crust With Sorghum Flour
  • Keto Coconut Cream Pie
  • Sugar-Free Lemon Cream Pie
  • Sugar-Free Low-Carb Raspberry Yogurt Pie
  • Flaky Gluten Free & Keto Hand Pies
  • No-Sugar Sweet Potato Pie
  • Lemon Ricotta Pie
  • No Bake Sugar Free Strawberry Cheesecake
  • Flaky Keto Pie Crust
  • Five Onion Tart
  • Snickers Pie-Low Carb, Sugar Free
  • Keto Gluten Free Bakewell Tart
  • Sugar Free Pecan Pie
  • Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie
  • Keto Key Lime Pie

Instructions

  1. Choose your favorite recipe from our list of Sugar Free Pies!
  2. Wave your magic wand to make it your own special recipe!
  3. Leave a comment on our Facebook page and share your new dish.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe